Words from the (Investment) Wise for the Week That Was (May 18 - 24, 2009)
by Prieur du Plessis
"Words from the Wise" this week comes to you a bit later than usual and in
a shortened format as my "day-job" demands keep me from doing my customary
commentary. However, a full dose of excerpts from interesting news items and
quotes from market commentators is provided.
Stock markets kicked off the last week on a high note, but then the US parted
ways with other markets as the remaining four days went downhill for American
stocks. In contrast, global markets in general had only one down day on Thursday.
In addition to non-US equities, risky assets such as commodities, oil, gold,
silver and platinum, and high-yielding currencies performed strongly amid fresh
signs of "less bad" economic and financial conditions. However, safe-haven
trades such as the US dollar and government bonds got whacked, especially following
Standard & Poor's decision on Thursday to mark down its medium-term outlook
for the UK's AAA credit rating from "stable" to "negative". This raised concerns
that the US may face a similar fate.
As the implications of surging government debt levels move to center stage,
the US Debt Clock makes for sobering reading. Click here or
on the image below for the live version.
David Rosenberg, Merrill Lynch's former chief North American economist, who
has just commenced duty with buy-side firm Gluskin
Sheff & Associates, commented as follows: "While the UK government
debt-to-GDP ratio is around 40%, the rating agencies are looking at 100% in
coming years. The US government debt/GDP ratio right now is near 65%, but clearly
heading higher. It seems as though 100%+ is the trigger point for downgrades
...
"So the view out there that the US is about to receive a credit downgrade
despite the dramatic expansion of the government balance sheet is a little
premature. For now, it makes for nice cocktail conversation but as super-sized
as the deficit is (13% of GDP), there is enough room in the debt ratio that
the US would likely have to run three more years of this sort of fiscal policy
to be seen as a candidate for a downgrade."
The performance of the major asset classes is summarized by the chart below.
Following the previous week's bruising, the MSCI World Index last week gained
2.2% (YTD +2.3%) and the MSCI Emerging Markets Index 5.4% (YTD +31.6%).
Similarly, the major US indices reversed course, but in a much more subdued
fashion, as seen from the fairly flat movements of the major indices: S&P
500 Index (+0.5%, YTD -1.8%), Dow Jones Industrial Index (+0.1%, YTD -5.7%),
Nasdaq Composite Index (+0.7%, YTD +7.3%) and Russell 2000 Index (+0.4%, YTD
-4.4%).
The Nasdaq remains the only major US index still in the black for the year
to date, finding itself in the company of the majority of emerging and mature
markets.
India's BSE 30 Sensex Index (+14.1%) was the strongest market for the week,
having rallied by 17.3% on Monday on unexpected election results. This was
the biggest one-day gain in the 30-year history of the Index.
Elsewhere, returns ranged from top performers Sri Lanka (+12.5%), Cyprus (+12.3%),
Luxembourg (+9.4%), Macedonia (+9.0%) and Nigeria (+8.8%), to Ghana (-8.9%),
Malta (-1.2%), Palestine (-1.2%), Côte d'Ivoire (-1.1%) and Uganda (-1.1%),
which experienced headwinds. Japan's Nikkei 225 Average (-0,4%) put in the
worst performance among the major markets. (Click here to
access a complete list of global stock market movements, as supplied by Emerginvest.)
John Nyaradi (Wall Street
Sector Selector) reports that as far as exchange-traded funds (ETFs)
are concerned, Indian ETFs such as WisdomTree India Earnings (EPI) (+22.7%)
and PowerShares India (PIN) (+21.6%) were going great guns. Other top-performing
sectors were concentrated among commodity funds, helped by investors becoming
less risk averse. Strong performers included MarketVectors TR GoldMiners
(GDX) (+10.6%), United States Oil (USO) (+4.1%), and iShares Silver Trust
(SLV) (+4.6%).
Conversely, safe-haven-related ETFs - US dollar and government bonds - and
regional banks reacted negatively, with iShares Dow Jones US Regional Banks
Index (IAT) declining by -5.3%, iShares 20+ Year Treasury Bond (TLT) by -4.8%,
and PowerShares DB US Dollar Index Bullish (UUP) by -2.9%.
On the credit front, I updated my regular "Credit
Crisis Watch" last week and concluded as follows:
"In summary, the past few months have seen impressive progress on the credit
front, with a number of spreads having declined substantially since their 'panic
peaks'. The TED spread (down to 0.48% from 4.65% on October 10), LIBOR-OIS
spread (down to 0.45%% from 3.64% on October 10) and GSE mortgage spreads have
all narrowed considerably since the record highs.
"In addition, corporate bonds have seen a strong improvement, although high-yield
spreads remain at elevated levels. Credit derivative indices for companies
in all the major geographical regions have also shown a marked tightening since
the November highs.
"Most indications are that the credit market tide has turned on the back of
the massive reflation efforts orchestrated by central banks worldwide and that
the credit system has started thawing. However, although the convalescence
process seems to be well on track, it still has a way to go before confidence
in the world's financial system returns to more 'normal' levels and liquidity
starts to move freely again."
The quote du jour relates to the monetization process and belongs to Bill
King (The King Report): "The
dollar collapsed and inflation accelerated with Bernanke's Treasury monetization.
More monetization will yield higher inflation and a dollar debacle. The Fed,
Treasury, administration and solons are being checked by the dollar and commensurate
inflation ... You can reference Jimmy Carter, G. William Miller, stagflation,
dollar flight, the Misery Index and public revolt if you don't believe us."
In other news, Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner on Wednesday testified
before the Senate Banking Committee, saying that "there are important indications
that our financial system is starting to heal", and that the Treasury would
soon be introducing its plan to team up with private investors to buy toxic
assets from the banks. Separately, President Barack Obama on Friday signed
into law a bill to put new restrictions on the credit-card industry, compelling
card issuers to spell out their terms in fewer words - in plain English - and
treat customers more fairly.
Next, a quick textual analysis of my week's reading. No surprises here, with
the word "banks" dominating the media. Strikingly, "dollar" is increasingly
prominent as the greenback hit a five-month low.
Back to the stock market. An analysis of the moving averages of the major
US indices shows the spring rally having encountered resistance at the important
200-day line and/or the early January highs. The highs of May 8 are the most
immediate target to the upside, whereas the levels from where the rally commenced
on March 9 should hold in order for base formations to remain in force.
For more about key levels and the most likely short-term direction of the
S&P 500, Adam Hewison of INO.com prepared
another of his popular technical analyses. Click here to
access the short presentation. (The analysis was done on Wednesday with the
Index at 912, but is still as relevant as it was a few days ago.)
Jeffrey Saut (Raymond James) said: "...
our sense is the equity markets are forming at least a near- to intermediate-term
TOP and we are cautious. As Sy Harding writes, 'Our Seasonal Timing Strategy
is now in its unfavorable season. Our non-seasonal Market Timing Strategy is
now on a new sell signal. We remain on the recent buy signal for gold and remain
neutral on bonds.'
"Indeed, over the past few weeks technology, retail, housing, and cyclicals
have broken their relative strength uptrends that have been intact since the
March lows. Whether this turns out to be just another shallow correction, or
something more enduring, will likely be determined by those groups whose relative
strength still remains intact. Such groups include financials, agriculture,
chemicals, oil drillers, and emerging markets."
"Speaking of stocks, with the Averages backing off from their thrust at the
May highs, it's clear (at least to me) that the market is having second thoughts
about the picture," said Richard Russell, venerable writer of the Dow
Theory Letters. "My guess is that those thoughts have to do with the sliding
dollar, the sinking bonds with their higher yields - and last but not least
- the surging price of gold. Dollar down, bonds down, gold up, it all fits
together - trouble."
Economy
The Ifo World Economic Climate Indicator also
rose in the second quarter of 2009 for the first time since autumn 2007. According
to the Survey, "The rise in the indicator was the result of more favorable
expectations for the coming six months; the assessment of the current economic
situation, however, worsened again, falling to a new record low."
Economic expectations have improved in all major regions, especially in North
America and Asia. But the expectations for the coming six months for Western
Europe, Central and Eastern Europe, Russia and Latin America are also clearly
upwards.
Turning to the US, a snapshot of the week's economic data is provided below.
(Click on the dates to see Northern
Trust's assessment of the various data releases.)
May
22
• Road map for the near-term performance of the economy
May
21
• Index of Leading Indicators signals improving economic conditions
• Auto industry events will continue to distort jobless claims data
May
19
• Plunge in multi-family starts conceals small gain of single-family units
May
18
• Homebuilders Survey records improvement; will new home sales follow?
• Discount window borrowing continues to trend down
The chart below shows the Conference Board's Leading Economic Indicator, which
rose 1% month over month and is comparable to the increases seen at the end
of the last recession.
According to Moody's Economy.com, the minutes from
the Federal Open Market Committee's meeting late in April indicate that participants
were more optimistic about the economy than they had been at their previous
meeting in mid-March. While the economy remained in recession, there were numerous
signs that the pace of contraction was slowing down.
"FOMC members agreed that the steps the committee had previously taken appeared
to be providing an economic stimulus and that the Federal Reserve should continue
with its previously announced policy actions, in particular 'quantitative easing',
an expansion of the Fed's balance sheet through the purchase of longer-term
Treasuries, designed to bring down long-term interest rates," said Moody's
Economy.com.
Gallup's latest Consumer
Mood poll, dealing with economic and market implications, shows that
only 6% of Americans have a "positive" mood on the economy, but that the
percentage of those that are "negative" has dropped significantly since
early March when the stock market advance started. Also, Americans whose
mood is described as "mixed" have increased from the mid-teens to 36% as
the negativity has subsided.
"This 'mixed' mood goes along with the 'green shoots' theory that some things
are getting better and most things have stopped getting worse," said Bespoke. "With
Americans moving from 'negative' to 'mixed' before turning 'positive', does
this imply that we'll have a U-shaped recovery instead of a V?"
The last quote comes from Nouriel
Roubini, via a Facebook status update: "The Green Shooters are starting
to sweat and getting cold feet as evidence of pestilent yellow weeds is mushrooming."
Click here for
a summary of Wachovia's weekly economic and financial commentary.
Markets
The performance chart obtained from the Wall
Street Journal Online shows how different global financial markets performed
during the past week.
Louis Pasteur said: "Chance
favors the prepared mind." Hopefully the "Words from the Wise" reviews
will assist Investment Postcards readers
with the ongoing preparation that is required to manage your money wisely.
I hope you're enjoying a great Memorial Day holiday weekend.
CNBC: PIMCO's El-Erian on this week's selloff "Mohamed El-Erian, CEO
and co-CIO of PIMCO, discusses this week's market selloff and the possibility
of the US losing its AAA credit rating."
The New York Times: Banks raised billions, Geithner says "The country's
biggest banks have made moves to bolster their balance sheets by about $56
billion since the government disclosed the results of its financial 'stress
tests' two weeks ago, Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner said Wednesday.
"Testifying before the Senate Banking Committee, Mr. Geithner said that the
financial system had begun to 'heal', and that the Treasury would soon be introducing
the next phase of its financial rescue effort - the plan to team up with private
investors to buy billions of dollars in toxic assets from banks.
"'There are important indications that our financial system is starting to
heal,' Mr. Geithner told lawmakers, though he cautioned that it was still too
early to talk about an 'exit strategy' for the government.
"But lawmakers in both parties complained that the $700 billion aid plan,
known as the Troubled Asset Relief Program, or TARP, had yet to revive bank
lending in many parts of the country.
"'The frustration level is mounting on an hourly basis,' said Senator Christopher
J. Dodd, Democrat of Connecticut and chairman of the banking committee.
"Senator Richard C. Shelby, Republican of Alabama who voted against the entire
program last year, said the Treasury had 'treated many sick banks' but 'certainly
has not cured them'.
"In describing the banking system, Mr. Geithner, said that the country's largest
financial institutions had raised billions by issuing common stock and new
debt, including $8 billion in bonds not guaranteed by the government."
Source: Jack Healy and Edmund Andrews, The
New York Times, May 20, 2009.
Financial Times: Smaller US banks need additional $24 billion "Small
and medium-sized US banks must raise some $24 billion to meet the capital standards
set by the government in its stress tests of large institutions, research for
the Financial Times shows.
"News of the potential capital shortfall could increase pressure on many of
the 7,900 US banks that form the backbone of the US financial system.
"As many as 500 more banks could close, according to investment bank Sandler
O'Neill, which carried out the research.
"Since this month's release of the tests for the 19 largest banks, regulators
and investors have increased their focus on the next tier of lenders, amid
concerns some of them might struggle to survive if the economy worsens.
"The government's stress-case would result in capital shortfalls for 38% of
the 200 banks below the 19 largest financial institutions, leading to a deficit
of around $16.2 billion in common equity, according to Sandler O'Neill.
"Applying similar criteria to the remaining 7,700 banks in the US would result
in a further $7.8 billion capital deficit.
"The banks have to repay a combined $27 billion in aid from the Troubled Asset
Relief Programme (Tarp) but they could do that from internal resources rather
than raising more funds.
"The US Treasury has said that it does not intend to extend the stress tests
beyond the 19 top institutions it examined. But analysts say that the public
release of the government's test methodology and capital adequacy philosophy
means that the tests' standards will become a model for the rest of the US
banking system."
Source: Saskia Scholtes, Julie MacIntosh and Francesco Guerrera, Financial
Times, May 17, 2009.
Financial Times: US banks scramble to repay bail-out cash "US banks
are scrambling to be in the first wave of lenders to repay Washington bail-out
funds after the authorities told Wall Street executives they would allow five
or six big financial groups to return taxpayers' money before the rest of the
industry.
"Bankers said they expected the Treasury and Federal Reserve - which doled
out billions of dollars from the $700 billion troubled assets relief programme
to lenders last year - to name the first repayers in the next few weeks.
"The authorities decided to allow a group of banks to return the funds, rather
than approving individual applications, to avoid a 'rush for the exit' by lenders
vying for bragging rights of being the first to repay, said people close to
the matter.
"The timing of the repayment and the number and identity of the banks in the
first wave is still under discussion.
"Goldman Sachs, JPMorgan Chase and American Express, which were found not
to need additional equity in the recent stress tests, are almost certain to
be in the first grouping."
Source: Francesco Guerrera and Krishna Guha, Financial
Times, May 18, 2009.
Bloomberg: Geithner says Treasury may move "quickly" to sell TARP warrants "Treasury
Secretary Timothy Geithner said he's inclined to 'quickly' sell warrants the
government got when injecting capital into banks, offering prospects of a speedy
exit to lenders seeking to retire government stakes.
"'In general, our objective will be to sell these warrants as quickly as we
can,' Geithner told the Senate Banking Committee today. 'What I'm reluctant
to do is have the government be in a position where we hold these investments
for a long period of time, longer than is desirable, in the hopes that we're
going to maximize value.'
"The Treasury received warrants with nearly every capital injection it made
with its $700 billion bank-rescue fund, called the Troubled Asset Relief Program.
As big banks begin to pay back the assistance years earlier than expected,
the Treasury may use market bidding to break a logjam over how to value a key
component of the government's equity stakes.
"The total value of the government's bank warrants is roughly $5 billion,
according to Treasury calculations.
"If the Treasury can't agree with banks about the value of the warrants, the
government may try to sell them at auctions, a Treasury official said in an
interview this week. That's because investor offers may be the only way to
put a clear value on warrants that can vary widely depending on the model used."
Source: Rebecca Christie, Bloomberg,
May 20, 2009.
Financial Times: US poised for finance regulation shake-up "Congress
will next month start the biggest regulatory overhaul of the US financial system
in decades, bringing into the open a frantic lobbying effort between banks,
regulators and policymakers on what it contains and who pays for it.
"The House financial services committee, chaired by Democrat Barney Frank,
will hold hearings early in June into reforms outlined by Timothy Geithner,
Treasury secretary, say people familiar with the timetable.
"But the complexity, coupled with a crowded legislative agenda, means one
key pillar - a resolution authority allowing a regulator to seize a failing
bank holding company - is not likely to be put in place until year-end.
"The cost of the resolution authority and a proposed systemic risk regulator
could be borne by both large banks and small, according to people involved,
in spite of the entreaties from the hundreds of small US institutions that
they should not pay a levy.
"Cam Fine, chief executive of the Independent Community Bankers of America,
said the authority 'should be totally funded by those institutions that are
regarded as systemically important or too big to fail'. He said he 'felt pretty
good about where we stand' and was confident of Mr Geithner's support.
"Other smaller institutions such as hedge funds are also expressing concern
that they will suffer from severe 'haircuts on contracts' entered into as counterparties
with the seized institution, according to one lobbyist.
"Sheila Bair, the chairman of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, has
been lobbying for early introduction of seizure powers that could be used to
take over a large systemically important bank if it was severely weakened by
another sudden downturn in the economy.
"Mr Geithner has said new powers would allow for an orderly winding up of
a systemically important institution, avoiding a repeat of the messy fall-out
from Lehman Brothers' collapse last year or the expensive bail-out of AIG,
the insurer."
Source: Tom Braithwaite, Sarah O'Connor and Krishna Guha, Financial
Times, May 17, 2009.
The New York Times: Senate passes bill to restrict credit card practices "The
Senate voted overwhelmingly on Tuesday to put new restrictions on the credit
card industry, passing a bill whose backers say will make card-issuers spell
out their terms in fewer words, using plain English, and treat customers more
fairly.
"The 90-to-5 vote, following a 357-to-70 vote in the House on April 30, made
it likely that President Obama will have a measure on his desk before the Memorial
Day recess. The differences between the House and Senate versions will have
to be worked out, but given the political atmosphere it seems likely that the
House-Senate negotiations will move quickly.
"The industry has asserted that the legislation may backfire, forcing banks
to issue fewer credit cards at greater cost to the current cardholders and
making credit harder to get at a time when many Americans need it."
Financial Times: UK looks towards sale of bank stakes "Britain has
begun taking soundings with sovereign wealth funds and other investors about
selling stakes in its part-nationalised banks as it seeks to tap into a revival
of stock market confidence in the financial sector.
"UK Financial Investments, which manages the government's 43.5% stake in Lloyds
Banking Group and 70% stake in Royal Bank of Scotland, could start the process
of selling tranches in both banks within a year, according to people briefed
on the organisation's plans.
"Lloyds on Monday launched an open offer to replace £4 billion of preference
shares held by the government with new ordinary shares. The move followed the
weekend announcement of the planned departure of Sir Victor Blank as Lloyds
chairman amid investor unrest over his role in the bank's much-criticised takeover
of HBOS last year.
"UKFI has already had substantial contact with potential investors, including
UK institutions and foreign organisations such as sovereign wealth funds, to
gauge their interest.
"'A lot of people around the world think once you get through the losses the
earnings power of these banks will be formidable,' said one person familiar
with the situation.
"The organisation is likely to exit its stakes in tranches over a period of
time although 'these might be quite large dribs and drabs', according to people
close to the matter."
Source: Jane Croft and Patrick Jenkins, Financial
Times, May 18, 2009.
BCA Research: Euro area banks - stressful situation "The euro area's
attempt to stress-test the banking system is likely to prove fruitless.
"The Committee of European Banking Supervisors has designed a set of scenarios,
which are currently being used by national regulators and central banks to
evaluate the euro area banking system. However, the stress tests will not conclude
until September, the assumptions used and the results will remain a secret,
and the focus will not be on individual banks but rather the system as a whole.
"It is hard to argue that this process will help provide clarity regarding
bank balance sheets or ease investor concerns over the potential for enormous
losses. Up to the end of last year, European banks (excluding the UK) had only
accounted for $224 billion in bad loans. The IMF estimates that another $875
billion will need to be written down by the end of 2010, compared with another
$550 billion in the US banking system. Losses for the next two years are enough
to wipe out all of the European banking system's tangible capital, before considering
earnings over the period.
"The IMF results are roughly consistent with our own calculations for the
top 20 banks. It would take just over 2% in writedowns of assets to eliminate
all tangible equity (US banks have roughly 3%). It is possible that banks'
access to private capital will improve and, together with future operating
earnings, further asset writedowns will be easily absorbed. Still, the stress
tests as currently envisioned will do little to bring clarity to the situation
or restore investor trust.
"One positive development is that the German Cabinet has agreed to a 'bad
bank' scheme to remove toxic assets from bank balance sheets. The proposal
still needs parliamentary approval but would be helpful, at least for the German
financial sector."
The New York Times: GM draws another $4 billion from Treasury "General
Motors, facing the almost certain prospect of a bankruptcy filing, said Friday
that it had drawn another $4 billion from the Treasury Department, raising
its total from the government to $19.4 billion.
"GM originally said that it would need an additional $2.6 billion from the
government to operate through June 1, but added $1.4 billion to that amount.
"The company, in a regulatory filing, also increased - to $7.6 billion - the
amount it said it would need from the Treasury after June 1, the deadline set
by the Obama administration for a restructuring plan.
"GM gave the Treasury a note for $266.8 million as security against the additional
money that it borrowed on Friday. The financing does not appear to be the last
that GM will draw, according to the filing with the Securities and Exchange
Commission.
"It says that by June 1, it expects to have borrowed a total of $21.4 billion
from the Treasury. In its original request to Congress last fall, GM asked
for $18 billion in loans to keep it afloat while it restructured. With its
latest injection from Treasury, it has surpassed that request.
"Lawyers for GM and the government are preparing documents for a GM bankruptcy
filing, which is expected to come around June 1.
"People briefed on GM's finances said the automaker would require debtor-in-possession
financing during its reorganization of $40 billion to $70 billion.
"If GM drew the full $70 billion while in bankruptcy, the government would
have provided the company with more than $90 billion in total, including the
money it has drawn to date.
"Also on Friday, the Canadian Auto Workers union said that it had reached
a second cost-cutting agreement with General Motors of Canada, even as bondholders
for the parent company stood firm in their decision to reject an offer to convert
their debt into GM stock.
"The automaker has offered its bondholders 225 shares for each $1,000 worth
of debt, which over all would give them a 10% stake in the company.
"The company has said that it needs 90% approval from its bondholders by Tuesday
if it is to avoid a bankruptcy filing. But the committee of GM's biggest bondholders,
which represent 20% of the overall debt, said there was no support for the
current offer. Bondholders have said that competing creditors, like the UAW,
have received better treatment."
ClipSyndicate: In-depth look at GM bankruptcy looming "Interview and
discussion with White House Economic Adviser, Austan Goolsbee. He talks about
President Obama's plans for GM's restructuring, the resignation of AIG CEO
Edward Liddy and the impact of the credit-card bill that the President will
sign this afternoon [Friday]."
Financial Times: Declining Libor "As a barometer of the financial crisis,
it's been hard to beat Libor, the London interbank offered rate for borrowing
short-term funds in the banking system.
"On Wednesday, dollar Libor for the benchmark three-month sector set at 0.71625
per cent, extending its run of declines for 36 straight days. A comparison
of Libor with the Fed funds rate shows that the gap between these two rates
is at its lowest level since February 2008. Traders forecast further improvement
on Thursday. The mood is a world away from the stressful peaks of Bear Stearns'
rescue last March and the failure of Lehman Brothers in September when Libor
took a rocket ship to the moon.
"Further evidence that the banking system is stabilising is seen by activity
in financial commercial paper. Lending for three months is back above that
of the one-month sector for the first time since late January when the Federal
Reserve's support temporarily boosted 90-day paper. Quantitative easing and
the smooth completion of the stress tests for banks has eased tension. That
has helped nurture the recovery in risky assets.
"For the banking system, however, there are still signs of dislocation. Swap
spreads, the difference between government bond yields and money market rates
and a measure of bank credit quality, remain some way from looking normal.
Liquidity also remains questionable as banks seek stronger balance sheets and
raise capital to pay back government support.
"The steady declines in three-month Libor have also reduced the Ted spread,
which compares the bank lending rate with that of three-month Treasury bills.
After surging to record levels, the much lower Ted spread is another good sign.
But with bills only yielding 0.18 per cent, it's clear there remains an aversion
to lending money at the much higher unsecured rate of three-month Libor."
Ifo: Ifo World Economic Climate brightens "The Ifo World Economic Climate
Indicator rose in the second quarter of 2009 for the first time since autumn
2007. The rise in the indicator was the result of more favourable expectations
for the coming six months; the assessment of the current economic situation,
however, worsened again, falling to a new record low.
"The economic expectations improved in all major regions, especially in North
America and Asia. But also in Western Europe, Central and Eastern Europe, Russia
and Latin America the expectations for the coming six months have been clearly
corrected upwards. In contrast, the current economic situation in all major
regions is still assessed as markedly unfavourable, with the worst appraisals
coming from North America and Western Europe."
Nouriel Roubini (Forbes): Don't believe the optimists "Recent data
suggest that the rate of economic contraction in the global economy is slowing
down, and that we are closer than we were six months ago to the trough of the
recent severe global recession.
"But while the rate of economic contraction is now lower than the free-fall
and near-depression experienced by many economies in the fourth quarter of
2008 and the first of 2009, the recent optimism that 'green shoots' of recovery
will lead to the recession to bottom out by the middle of this year - and that
recovery to potential growth will rapidly occur in 2010 - appears grossly misplaced,
for three noteworthy reasons.
"First, the current deep and protracted U-shaped recession in the US and other
advanced economies will continue through all of 2009, rather than reach a trough
in the middle of this year as expected by the optimists.
"Second, rather than a rapid V-shaped recovery, growth will remain sluggish
and sub-par for at least two years into all of 2010 and 2011. A couple of quarters
of more rapid growth cannot be ruled out as we get out of this recession toward
the end of the year or early next year as firms rebuild inventories and the
effects of the monetary and fiscal stimulus reach a delayed peak. But structural
weaknesses of the US and the global economy will cause both a below-trend growth
and even the risk of a reduction of potential growth itself.
"Third, we cannot rule out a double-dip W-shaped recession, with the wings
of a tentative recovery of growth in 2010 at risk of being clipped toward the
end of that year or in 2011. This will result from a perfect storm of rising
oil prices, rising taxes and rising nominal and real interest rates on the
public debt of many advanced economies, as concerns rise about medium-term
fiscal sustainability and the risk that monetization of fiscal deficits will
lead to inflationary pressures after two years of deflationary pressures."
Casey's Charts: Recession hits the Treasury "The magnitude of the recession
was underscored by the latest numbers from the US Treasury: last month's individual
income tax receipts dropped 44% and corporate tax revenue plunged 65% compared
to April 2008. Alarming news, as April is historically the biggest collection
month of the year and usually results in a sizable budget surplus for the month.
"As Casey Research Chief Economist Bud Conrad correctly predicted back in
January, the initial $1.2 trillion deficit for 2009 was grossly underestimated.
The Congressional Budget Office estimate is not only riddled with low-ball
expenditure figures and accounting trickery, it also failed to anticipate a
precipitous collapse in tax revenues."
Asha Bangalore (Northern Trust): Index of Leading Indicators signals improving
economic conditions "The Conference Board's Index of Leading Economic
Indicators (LEI) moved up 1.0% after a string of monthly declines between
October 2008 and March 2009. The increase of the index in April reflects
a widespread improvement as seen in the 70% diffusion index for April.
"On a year-to-year basis, the LEI fell 3.0% in April, after a 4.0% drop in
the November-December months of 2008. The year-to-year change in LEI on a quarterly
basis dropped 3.6% in the second quarter (based on April data). It is the second
consecutive decline which is smaller than the 3.9% drop of the fourth quarter
of 2008.
"The chart below illustrates that the year-to-year change in LEI bottoms out
well ahead of the end of a recession. The table lists the details related to
this observation. Based on the history of the LEI, the 3.9% drop in the fourth
quarter could be the bottom for the current cycle; we will need additional
monthly data to confirm this assessment.
"At the present time, we can temporarily conclude that the worst of the decline
in economic activity is part of history. The number of quarters, deduced from
the history of the LEI, before recovery commences after the year-to-year change
of the LEI has recorded a bottom for the cycle varies between one and four
quarters."
Asha Bangalore (Northern Trust): Auto industry events will continue to
distort jobless claims data "Initial jobless claims fell 12,000 to 631,000
during the week ended May 16. The prior week's reading of initial jobless
claims was raised to 643,000 from the earlier estimate of 631,000.
"The large movements of initial jobless claims in the past two weeks from
605,000 in the week ended May 2 is largely due to auto industry events. The
four-week moving average of initial jobless claims is 628,500 and it appears
to have peaked in the first week of April at 658,750. The Chrysler and GM plant
shutdowns and reopening in the next few months are most likely to distort jobless
claims data.
"The tentative conclusion is that initial jobless claims are trending down,
albeit holding at a high level.
"The 1990-91 and 2001 recessions were both jobless recoveries with jobless
claims posting significant declines only well after the recovery was underway.
There is a strong likelihood the current recession may also be followed by
a jobless recovery. We will need to see significant and consecutive weekly
declines in jobless claims to declare that the worst is behind us."
Asha Bangalore (Northern Trust): Homebuilders survey records improvement,
will new home sales follow? "The Housing Market Index (HMI) of the National
Association of Home Builders rose to 16 in May from 14 in April. The HMI
has advanced in three out of the four months ended May. Sales of new single-family
homes rose 8.2% in February and edged down 0.6% in March. The sales tally
for new single-family homes during April will be published on May 28. There
is a strong positive correlation with the HMI and actual sales of new homes."
Asha Bangalore (Northern Trust): Plunge in multi-family starts conceals
small gain of single-family units "Housing starts fell 12.8% to an annual
rate of 458,000, a new record low. Total housing starts have fallen 80% from
the peak in January 2006.
"In April, multi-family starts plunged 46.1% and single-family starts advanced
2.8%. Single-family starts held steady in February and rose 0.3% in March.
Starts of new single-family homes have declined each month during July 2007-January
2009, with the exception of a small increase in May 2008. The recent movements
suggest that single-family starts appear to be establishing a bottom.
"At the same time, the elevated level of unsold new single-family homes (10.7-month
supply in March, down from peak of 12.5-month supply in January) is a drag
on new construction. The good news is that inventories of new unsold single-family
homes appear to have peaked in January 2009.
"Pulling together the different pieces of news from the housing market, the
housing starts report for April leans on the side of optimism because the pace
of decline could have accelerated further. Instead, it appears that there is
a moderating trend in place with support from other reports. The key to a complete
recovery is, of course, a turnaround in employment conditions."
Bespoke: Country returns "With global equity markets still in rally
mode, below we highlight the year to date performance of the major indices
for 83 countries around the world. After nearly every country was down earlier
in the year, 62 out of the 83 are now up in 2009.
"Peru is up the most at 72.92%, while Costa Rica is down the most at -39.94%.
And the BRIC (Brazil, Russia, India, China) countries are significantly outperforming
the developed G-7 countries. Russia, India, and China rank 2nd, 3rd, and 4th
in terms of year to date performance, and Brazil isn't far behind in 10th place.
"Canada has been the best performing G-7 country with a gain of 12.62% in
2009, but it ranks 35th out of 83. The rest of the G-7 countries are bunched
up in the 0%-5% range, which is closer to the bottom of the list than the top.
And the US is the worst of the seven with gains of less than 1%. While the
markets here in the US have rallied nicely off of their March lows, most other
countries have bounced back even more 2009."
Bespoke: Recent performance of key ETFs "For those interested in a
quick snapshot of how various ETFs across all asset classes have performed
recently, below we highlight their 1-day, 5-day, and 1-month performance. As
far as equities go, there was lots of red today [Thursday], but there's still
lots of green over the last month."
Bespoke: Strategists keep 2009 S&P 500 price target at 949 "The
Wall Street strategists that Bloomberg polls each week haven't changed their
year-end S&P 500 price targets since mid-March. But by doing nothing, they're
collective price target has gotten much closer to the actual level of the index
since the market has rallied so much.
"At the start of the year, strategists as a whole were looking for a year-end
S&P 500 price of 1,049, which would have meant a gain of 16.2% for the
year. When the market was down more than 20% in early March, this bullish price
target was pretty bad. As the market fell, strategists cut their year-end target,
which is now 100 points lower at 949. But as the market has risen, they haven't
increased their expectations yet, so they are now just looking for another
4.19% gain through the end of the year.
"UBS and JP Morgan remain the most bullish of the bunch with a target of 1,100.
And four strategists have price targets below the current level of the S&P
500, with Barclays the most bearish at 757. At the start of the year, Barclays
was looking for 874."
Jeffrey Saut (Raymond James): A stoopers' market " ... our sense is
the equity markets are forming at least a near- to intermediate-term TOP and
we are cautious. As Sy Harding writes, 'Our Seasonal Timing Strategy is now
in its unfavorable season. Our non-seasonal Market Timing Strategy is now on
a new sell signal (as of the close on May 13). We remain on the recent buy
signal for gold; and, remain neutral on bonds.'
"Indeed, over the past few weeks technology, retail, housing, and cyclicals
have broken their relative strength uptrends that have been intact since the
March lows. Whether this turns out to be just another shallow correction, or
something more enduring, will likely be determined by those groups whose relative
strength still remains intact. Such groups include financials, agriculture,
chemicals, oil drillers, and emerging markets.
"We continue to favor emerging/frontier markets and as ISI's Francois Trahan
notes, 'If you are bullish on US equities, global stock markets have become
more correlated over the past decade. And, generally when the S&P 500 has
risen it has underperformed the global equity complex.' Obviously, we agree
..."
David Fuller (Fullermoney): Substantiating bullish bias for equities "I
have described conditions as being more bullish than bearish for a number of
months. However such claims need to be substantiated by technical (market)
evidence, which is best monitored every day.
"I will review the process, discussed at length in Fullermoney, in what can
be a template for subscribers, not only for today's environment but also the
transition from every other bear to bull market in future:
"Climactic capitulation - Bear markets usually end in climactic fashion, which
is the phase of greatest capitulation and despondency. This is what happened
late last October and also in November.
"Base building - The most persistent capitulation stage marks the beginning
of the end for the bear market, which by definition, must also be the beginning
of the new bull market, although all one may see for some months will be ranging,
including some new lows by indices for less fundamentally attractive markets,
but also rising lows by indices for the next bull market's leaders.
"Reversion to the mean - If the bear really is ending or over, you will see
the evidence accumulate in several ways, which are different from the redistribution
bear market rallies which occur on the way down. Mean reversion (we use the
200-day moving average to measure this because it is a widely followed medium
to somewhat longer-term trend smoothing device) will become evident due to
a combination of different developments.
"Uptrends are established - Indices will be breaking up out of their ranging
bases, with the best performers establishing step sequence uptrends, one above
the other. These will eventually break above the 200-day MAs, which will eventually
turn upwards sometime later. The rising MA becomes a potential support level
during minor mean reversions throughout the duration of the new uptrend.
"Summary - Perspective is gained by monitoring many indices, as there will
inevitably be leaders and laggards. This is Fullermoney's commonality approach.
For instance, if stock market indices are mostly ranging but downward breaks
are no longer being maintained, in contrast to some rallies which are being
extended, one does not need to be a genius to deduce that demand (buying pressure)
is beginning to exceed supply (selling pressure).
"The performance of upside leaders when looking for evidence of market bottoms
and recovery potential is much more important than focussing on laggards, because
we are looking for a transition from bear, which includes all stock market
indices in its latter stages, to bull in which case markets will break away
from the prior downtrend one by one over time."
SmartMoney: Why Jeremy Grantham changed his mind "If people had paid
attention to veteran investor Jeremy Grantham over the past two years, their
investment portfolios would be looking much better than they likely are. While
many investors were caught up in bull-market euphoria in 2007, Grantham, who
oversees $85 billion for Boston-based institutional money-management firm GMO,
told anyone who would listen there was a global bubble: 'It's everywhere, in
everything'. Then, in early March of this year, when the market looked its
worst, he wrote that people needed to get over their fears and invest, because
US stocks were cheap and foreign stocks even cheaper."
With
25 years' experience in investment research and portfolio management, Dr Prieur
du Plessis is one of the most experienced and well-known investment professionals
in South Africa. More than 1 000 of his articles on investment-related topics
have been published in various regular newspaper, journal and Internet columns.
He also published a book, Financial Basics: Investment, in 2002.
He holds the following degrees: BSc (Quantity Surveying)
(Cape Town), HonsB (B & A) (cum laude) (Stellenbosch), MBA (cum laude)
(Stellenbosch); and DBA (Doctor of Financial Management) (Stellenbosch).
Prieur is chairman of the Plexus group
of companies, which he founded in 1995. Previously he was general manager:
portfolio management at Sanlam, responsible for the management of investment
portfolios with total assets in excess of $5 billion.
Plexus is a pioneer
in the mutual fund industry and has achieved a number of firsts under Prieur's
leadership. These include the authoritative Plexus Survey, a quarterly analysis
of the consistency of the performance of unit trust management companies, the
Plexus Offshore Survey, the Plexus Unit Trust Indices, and the PlexCrown Fund
Ratings.
Plexus is the South
African partner of John Mauldin, American
author of the most widely distributed investment newsletter in the world, and
also has an exclusive licensing agreement with California-based Research
Affiliates for managing and distributing its enhanced Fundamental Index™ methodology
in the Pan-African area.
In 2001 Prieur received the Santam/AHI Business Leader
of the Year award for corporate leadership, business acumen and entrepreneurial
flair. He was also profiled in the book South Africa's Leading Managers (2006).
Plexus received the AHI/Old Mutual Enterprise of the Year award in 1997 and
was also included in the book South Africa's Most Promising Companies (2005).
Prieur is 52 years old and lives with his wife, TV producer
and presenter Isabel Verwey, and two children in Welgemoed, Cape Town. His
recreational activities include long-distance running, motor cycling and reading.
He belongs to the Cape Town Club, Johannesburg Country Club, Gordon's Bay Yacht
Club and Swiss Social & Sports Club.
« Opinions expressed at SafeHaven are those of the
individual authors and do not necessarily represent the opinion of SafeHaven
or its management. Articles are available via RSS/XML. Please
visit RSSHelp for instructions. »