No Engine Left
The overnight equity-market rally lasted a full three minutes into the trading day before investors began the sell-the-news trade following the generally-expected pop on news that a debt ceiling deal was virtually passed. Although at this hour the bill has still not passed either house of Congress, but it seems likely that this bill (which no one seems to really want) will be making the trip to the White House for the President's signature shortly. The three minutes of rah-rah seemed sufficient, and stocks were already back to nearly unchanged - and bonds, rallying again - when the ISM Manufacturing figure printed 50.9, rather substantially below the 54.5 expectation and the lowest number since 2009.
The manufacturing sector is clearly at "stall speed;" the current level of the ISM index (see Chart) is roughly where the index was in 2007 and early 2008 just before the early stages of the recession helped trigger the mortgage/credit crisis. (The ISM itself says 41.2 is the dividing line between growth and recession, but that's not the same thing. An economy limping along at 1% growth is vulnerable to a shock.) Past is not prologue necessarily, but there is no doubt that the economy is just barely limping along trillions of dollars later.
The breakdown of the ISM was no more promising than the headline number. Every activity component fell: New Orders to 49.2 from 51.6, Production to 52.3 from 54.5, Inventories to 49.3 from 54.1, Order Backlogs to 45.0 from 49.0, and the important Employment subindex slipped to 53.5 from 59.9. This last point, combined with the continued buoyancy of the "Jobs Hard To Get" subindex of Consumer Confidence, suggests strongly that the Unemployment Rate might rise still further from the 9.2% reported last month.
There was not much further news, but volume was actually decent by 2011 standards. The VIX index slipped, although it remained fairly high. Stocks, which had spiked lower after ISM and then bled to new lows, bounced off a long trendline (see Chart) and staged an afternoon rally. The agenda of buyers was fairly clear - the 200-day moving average (also shown on the chart, currently at 1285.41) is a widely-followed indicator and a close of the S&P below that level would trigger a flip in some of the momentum crowd. So stocks rallied back above the 200-day moving average, then sunk back to it with three minutes to go before the close. The equity market in short is very finely balanced at the moment on a knife's edge.
200-day moving average and the uptrend-line are both being challenged.
This chart is probably important enough to look at a close-up of the last year or so (see Chart below). There are a ton of support levels in play: the 200-day moving average and the uptrend-line; the June lows at 1258, the March lows at 1249, and some people are watching the trend-line off those two lows, which comes in at 1262, as the 'neckline' of a big head-and-shoulders pattern that projects to, um, 1147.
Maybe you don't WANT to look at this too close-up.
There is a lot of hurt to be visited on the equity market if the bears get the ball rolling. Frankly, there is enough support that I wouldn't worry about it if equities were cheap. But where they are valued currently, and with the chance of a new recession which is clearly not priced, I think these support levels don't seem so formidable after all.
Soon to be noticed, after the debt ceiling deal is passed, is that Italian 10-year yields just went to new highs at 5.99%, and the 2-year is just below its recent highs (presently at 4.45%). Weakness in Italian debt markets is the circumstance that really causes investors to shudder. Observe the effect that Greece's problems had on the world's markets, and then reflect on the fact that Italy's GDP in 2009 was about six-and-a-half times as large as Greece's (an even larger multiple would apply currently, of course, thanks to Greek austerity measures) and a debt in 2010 of 5.5x (according to Eurostat, although presumably this doesn't include the 'hidden' Greek debt). Italy's economy is roughly the size of the UK. It is rated A+ by S&P, and so it is widely owned. A 6% rate is not a level at which panic should set in, especially when the curve is still sloped positively between 2-years and 10-years, but it is disturbing that these yields are going to new highs. "Too big to save" is the operative term here. And, as the recent U.S. data demonstrates, the global economy is sputtering. There is no engine left to pull the train up even a modest incline.
And that's the message from bonds. As nominal yields continue to decline, real yields are moving right in step. The 10-year inflation swap rate is at 2.78%, not appreciably off the post-2008 highs of 2.89%. But 10-year TIPS yields are at 0.33%, an all-time low. And that means the ratio of real yields is also at an all-time low of 11.7%. In other words, when you buy a 10-year nominal Treasury bond, only 12% of your return is compensation for the use of your money. The rest of the return is compensation for the decline in the value of your money. A more normal ratio is 40-70% (see Chart). But look at the dip at the end of 2007 into the beginning of 2008, before the teeth of the crisis had set in. What we are seeing now is bad news.
TIPS yields as a percentage of nominal bond yields, 10-year maturity
Tomorrow - assuming that the debt ceiling does in fact get passed and signed into law tonight; if not, then the economic data will be irrelevant for trading tomorrow - the data calendar includes Personal Income (Consensus: +0.2% from +0.3%) and Spending (Consensus: +0.1% from +0.0%), and the Core PCE Deflator (Consensus: +0.2% m/m vs +0.3% last, raising y/y to +1.4%). Car sales will be released throughout the day; they have recently taken a dive and until now the excuse has been the Japanese tsunami and channel effects from that disaster. The tsunami happened in March. At some point, either we need to upgrade our assessment of the long-term effects of the tsunami or acknowledge that some of the weakness may be exogenous. Maybe the tsunami is the next George W. Bush - we will keep blaming stuff on it for the next several years?