• 1 day New Study Equates Luxury Cars With Low Self-Esteem
  • 1 day Rio Tinto To Spend $1 Billion To Reduce Its Carbon Footprint
  • 2 days The Ultra-Wealthy Lost $140 Billion In One Day
  • 3 days Three Energy Casualties In The Coronavirus Crisis
  • 3 days Markets Crumble As Coronavirus Panic Peaks
  • 4 days Cobalt May Be The Key To Clean Hydrogen Fuel
  • 6 days How Taxpayers Are Bankrolling The EV Revolution
  • 6 days The Coronavirus Is Crushing China’s Car Market
  • 7 days Fighting For Survival In The Streaming War
  • 8 days Want A Job? Forget About A Bachelor’s Degree
  • 9 days Another Major Car Maker Is Backing Hydrogen
  • 9 days Are Americans Finally Sold On Soccer?
  • 10 days Is The Tech Bubble About To Burst?
  • 10 days Coronavirus Could Cost Tourism Industry $80 Billion
  • 10 days What Web Traffic Trends Can Tell Us About The World
  • 11 days Miners Face Greater Headwinds
  • 11 days Boris Johnson Proposes Billion Dollar Bridge To Northern Ireland
  • 13 days Goldman Slashes Oil Price Forecast By $10
  • 14 days Tesla Raises $2 Billion In Share Selloff
  • 14 days What The T-Mobile Takeover Of Sprint Really Means For Markets
How The Ultra-Wealthy Are Using Art To Dodge Taxes

How The Ultra-Wealthy Are Using Art To Dodge Taxes

More freeports open around the…

What's Behind The Global EV Sales Slowdown?

What's Behind The Global EV Sales Slowdown?

An economic slowdown in many…

Richard Mills

Richard Mills

Richard is host of www.aheadoftheherd.com and invests in the junior resource sector. His articles have been published on over 200 websites including: Wall Street Journal,…

Contact Author

  1. Home
  2. Markets
  3. Other

High Grade v Lower Grade

As a general rule, the most successful man in life is
the man who has the best information

One of the things I've learned over the years is that many retail investors in the resource market equate a higher grade deposit with a more profitable mine then a lower grade deposit would make. Unfortunately this false belief might be causing them to miss investment opportunities.

I'm going to use uranium to demonstrate what I want to convey in this article, I was doing research on the next uranium break out stock, but it could be pretty much any metal. Does higher grade mean more profit? Should investors be solely concerned about grade? Are there other concerns investors should be looking at?

What got me thinking about this subject was an excellent report that crossed my desk, a very interesting piece of research from Canaccord Capital.

In a June 16 report entitled "What is world class uranium anyway", Canaccord shows in quite plain and simple language that the profitability of lower grade deposits is about the same as the high-grade deposits.

I'm not a geologist, an analyst, or an engineer, I'm a retail investor. But I can read a chart and this chart speaks volumes to me:

Canaccord says "In Figure 3, we look at simplistic models of two uranium mines of vastly different grades: a high-grade underground mine averaging 15% U3O8 and a low-grade, open-pit mine averaging 1/1000 of the grade of the underground mine, 0.015% or 150 ppm U3O8. We use a long-term uranium price of US$70 per pound, common U3O8 recovery rates of 80%, and representative mining and milling costs. Despite the huge disparity in ore grade, the other inputs of scale and cost serve to offset the grade and result in virtually identical gross margins (revenue less operating costs)." (Underline and italics mine - author)

The low-grade open pit uranium deposit shows similar economics at 1/1000th of the grade as the much higher grade undergrounds mine! The reality is that ALL the new uranium production in the last five years has been from lower grade material. And when I started looking at the line up of near term producers - i.e. those with economic studies, they were all lower grade deposits.

One of the deposits I looked at was Forsys (FSY-TSX) Valencia deposit in Namibia. They have a new technical report from June 2009, but used June 2008 costs - the top of the market for costs. This new report shows costs of $40 per pound with a grade of 117 - 126 ppm - parts per million uranium. This works out to a grade of about 0.012% U3O8.

In their September 2008 technical study, Bannerman Resources (BAN-TSX) estimate they're operating costs to be about $25 per pound with a 100 ppm cut-off. Canadian brokerage firm Haywood Securities estimates all-in costs of $40 per pound in the first year for Bannerman's Etango project in Namibia.

Paladin Energy (PDN-TSX) says they have a $20 per pound cost with an 800 ppm grade.

So low-grade deposits can have low costs, and therefore high profitability. And stock prices did go up dramatically for many of these producing or near term production companies with the lower grade assets so there were profitable investment opportunities generated. Forsys still has a $7 per share bid on the table, and Paladin tripled from $1.50 to $4.50.

The bottom line for investors is to focus on profitability and mine life instead of solely on grade. This is because, despite the huge disparity in ore grade between deposits, your other inputs of scale/cost can offset the lower grade and this results in almost identical gross margins between the two types of deposits. Low grade can mean big profits for investors.

As for the next lower grade success story in the uranium sector here are a couple to watch:

Uracan Resources (URC-TSXv) trades at 22 cents, and with 40 million pounds compliant resource, has one of the lowest valuations per pound of any uranium company on the board. Their Double S deposit is also open in almost every direction. Uracan has the same 0.012% U3O8 grade that Forsys does. It has power & highway on the property and is only 7 km from a deepwater port. I like the fact that management has put low-grade assets into production before, when they were with Bema Gold.

Kivalliq Energy Corp. (KIV-TSXv) trades at 27 cents, and has a historical resource of 20 million pounds - but at a higher grade, around 1 per cent, or 10,000 ppm. I would consider this more like a medium grade deposit - if they hit. It would still be a large bulk tonnage, but underground operation. It's managed by John Robins, one of the best, but little known, explorationists in Canada. Kivalliq starts drilling in July.

Richard Mills does not own any shares of the companies mentioned in this article and no companies mentioned advertise on www.aheadoftheherd.com

If you're interested in the junior resource market and would like to learn more please come and visit us at. http://www.aheadoftheherd.com/


Back to homepage

Leave a comment

Leave a comment