• 7 hours America’s Workforce Elderly Workforce To Double By 2028
  • 13 hours Toyota Tests Solar-Powered Prius
  • 1 day Why The Gold Rally Flatlined
  • 2 days The Uranium Sector Can’t Catch A Break
  • 2 days Upcoming Fed Meeting Has Investors On Edge
  • 3 days Global Gold Sector Outlines Responsible Mining Principles
  • 3 days China’s Giant Vampire Fund Loses $120B
  • 4 days McDonalds To Roll Out Robot Drive-Thru Clerks
  • 4 days Savvy Investors Are Betting Big On This Little Data Company
  • 4 days How The Government Is Wasting Tax Money This Year
  • 4 days Supply Concerns Halt Expansion On Tianqi Lithium Plant
  • 5 days The World’s Biggest IPO Is Almost Here
  • 5 days The Relatively Of Money And Happiness
  • 5 days Wall Street Unfazed By Recession Fears
  • 6 days SoftBank Urges WeWork To Pause IPO Plans
  • 6 days Anti-Aging Market To Hit $55 Billion
  • 6 days JPM, Morgan Stanley Take Advisory Roles In Aramco IPO
  • 7 days Are Bonds In A Bubble?
  • 7 days The Unknown Media Giant Taking The World By Storm
  • 8 days From Millennial To Millionaire With One Simple Trick
Billionaires Are Pushing Art To New Limits

Billionaires Are Pushing Art To New Limits

Welcome to Art Basel: The…

Zombie Foreclosures On The Rise In The U.S.

Zombie Foreclosures On The Rise In The U.S.

During the quarter there were…

The Problem With Modern Monetary Theory

The Problem With Modern Monetary Theory

Modern monetary theory has been…

  1. Home
  2. Markets
  3. Other

Markit vs. ISM Services: Markit Economist Sticks with 1% Third Quarter GDP Estimate

On many days there are no economic reports. On some days, like today, there are many reports.

Rather than parrot mainstream media, I like to comment on the reports, dive into the details, and compare reports when applicable. This takes a bit of extra time.

Let's compare the Non-Manufacturing (Services) ISM report to the Markit Services PMI report, both out this morning.


Non-Manufacturing ISM

Index September August PP Change Direction Rate of Change Trend in Months
NMI® 57.1 51.4 5.7 growing Faster 80
Business Activity / Production 60.3 51.8 8.5 growing Faster 86
New Orders 60.0 51.4 8.6 Growing Faster 86
Employment 57.2 50.7 6.5 Growing Faster 4
Supplier Deliveries 51.0 51.5 -0.5 Slowing Slower 9
Inventories 51.5 48.0 3.5 growing From Contracting 1
Prices 54.0 51.8 2.2 Increasing Faster 6
Backlog of Orders 52.0 49.5 2.5 Growing From Contracting 1
New Export Orders 56.5 46.5 10.0 Growing From Contracting 1
Imports 51.0 50.5 0.5 Growing Faster 8
Inventory Sentiment 64.5 64.0 0.5 Too High Faster 232

That looks like an exceptionally good report. But is it believable? Let's see what Markit has to say.


Markit Services PMI

Markit Services PMI


Key Findings

  • Service sector activity rises at fastest pace since April...
  • ...despite softer upturn in new work during September
  • Employment growth eases to weakest since March 2013

U.S. service providers indicated an upturn in business activity growth from the six-month low recorded during August. Nonetheless, the pace of expansion remained modest and softer than its post-crisis trend, largely reflecting subdued new business gains in recent months. The latest survey highlighted that new work increased at the weakest rate since May, which contributed to another moderation in staff hiring across the service economy. The rise in payroll numbers during September was only marginal and the slowest seen for three-and-a-half years.

On average in the third quarter, the headline index posted 51.5, little-changed from 51.8 in Q2. Companies reporting a rise in business activity suggested that new product launches and the completion of unfinished work had helped to offset subdued underlying new order growth.

Volumes of new work received by service providers in September increased only moderately since the previous month. Moreover, the rate of new business growth eased to its joint-slowest since the post-crisis low recorded in March.

Anecdotal evidence suggested that generally subdued domestic economic conditions and uncertainty ahead of the presidential election had continued to act as headwinds to client spending.

Survey respondents cited fragile economic conditions, some noted hopes of a rebound in client spending after the election. Meanwhile, latest data showed that input cost inflation eased to its slowest since February 2015. This resulted in the weakest pace of output charge inflation for five months in September.


Comments from Chris Williamson, Markit Chief Business Economist

  1. "Coming hard on the heels of the IMF's downgrade to the US economic outlook, the upturn in the PMI is a welcome development and suggests that the pace of economic growth gained some momentum in September. However, take a longer look and it's clear that this is by no means a robust upturn."
  2. "Even with the latest increase the surveys are indicating that the economy is growing at an annualized rate of only 1%."
  3. "The survey responses reveal that a heightened degree of political uncertainty is subduing the economy, manifesting itself in particular in a marked slowdown in corporate hiring. Across both manufacturing and services the surveys point to the smallest monthly gain in jobs since April 2010, consistent with a mere 115,000 rise in non-farm payrolls."
  4. "Business optimism about the year ahead is at one of the lowest levels seen since the global financial crisis. The surveys therefore add ammunition to those arguing for the Fed to hold off with hiking interest rates again, at least until the dust settles after the election."


Markit vs. ISM

ISM provides a table that I manually input into Excel to create the HTML table shown at the top of this article. I like that table, but ISM provides no useful comments as does Markit.

Watching both reports now for quite some time, the ISM reports are generally more optimistic, sometimes far more optimistic than Markit. That's curious, because Markit and ISM should be covering the same companies. Variations ought to be random and small, not one-sided and large.

Judging from reported GDP as well as actual economic reports on manufacturing, Markit has been more aligned with actual incoming data than has ISM.

Chris Williamson stuck his neck out last quarter with a 1.0% GDP forecast. ISM does not provide a specific estimate based on its data. Last quarter, Williamson beat the economic consensus by a mile.

Moreover, Williamson has had a 1% economic forecast for 3rd quarter for quite some time. Meanwhile, the GDPNow forecast which hit a high of 3.8% on August 5, has plunged like a rock to 2.2%.

Judging from the trends of actual data, Markit seems to have the better case right now as to which report is more believable.


Related Economic Reports

 

Back to homepage

Leave a comment

Leave a comment