• 5 hours Tech Billionaire Takes Aim At Google
  • 7 hours Chinese Police Bust Largest Ever Illicit Crypto Mining Operation
  • 10 hours Expect A Pullback Before Gold's Next Major Rally
  • 12 hours Why Interest On Gold Matters
  • 1 day Ten Extravagant Food Items For The Wealthy Only
  • 1 day Why Saudi Arabia Won't Give Up On The Aramco IPO
  • 2 days $32 Million Crypto Heist Halts Tokyo Exchange
  • 2 days Is A Gold Selloff Looming?
  • 3 days Central Banks Are Stashing Gold And Dumping Treasuries
  • 3 days Three Cannabis Trends Flying Under Investors’ Radars
  • 4 days $1.3 Billion In Cocaine Found On JPMorgan Vessel
  • 4 days Amazon Teams Up With Lady Gaga To Win Over Generation Z
  • 4 days Dollar Falls As Powell Teases Rate Cuts
  • 5 days Will The World's First Trillion Dollar Company Ever Bounce Back?
  • 5 days Many Americans Will Never Stop Working
  • 5 days Mozilla vs DarkMatter: The Cyber Espionage End Game
  • 5 days Chile Cracks Down On Environmental Infractions
  • 5 days Warning Signs Emerge For Boeing
  • 6 days First Amendment Stands Strong In Trump vs. Twitter Showdown
  • 6 days Musk Bullish On Tesla Despite Executive Exodus
Market Sentiment At Its Lowest In 10 Months

Market Sentiment At Its Lowest In 10 Months

Stocks sold off last week…

The Problem With Modern Monetary Theory

The Problem With Modern Monetary Theory

Modern monetary theory has been…

John Rubino

John Rubino

John Rubino edits DollarCollapse.com and has authored or co-authored five books, including The Money Bubble: What To Do Before It Pops, Clean Money: Picking Winners…

Contact Author

  1. Home
  2. Markets
  3. Other

Major Inflection Point Coming

Fund manager John Hussman is always good for dramatic charts. Here’s a recent one:

Median Price/Revenue ratio of S&P500 Index Components 1986-2017

This ratio is even scarier than it looks, says Hussman:

Historically-reliable valuation measures now approach those observed at the 2000 bubble peak. Yet even this comparison overlooks the fact that in 2000, the overvaluation featured a subset of very large-capitalization stocks that were breathtakingly overvalued, while most stocks were more reasonably valued (see Sizing Up the Bubble for details). In many ways, the current speculative episode is worse, because it has extended to virtually all risk-assets. To offer some idea of the precipice the market has reached, this chart shows the median price/revenue ratio of individual S&P 500 component stocks. This median now stands just over 2.45, easily the highest level in history. The longer-term norm for the S&P 500 price/revenue ratio is less than 1.0. Even a retreat to 1.3, which we’ve observed at many points even in recent cycles, would take the stock market to nearly half of present levels.

One of the reasons share prices have risen so dramatically relative to revenues is that corporations are earning a lot more on each dollar of sales these days. How are they doing that? By squeezing their workers. The following chart, from the Economic Policy Institute shows labor’s share of corporate income plunging recently.

Labor's Share of Corporate Income

The next chart illustrates the same point from a different angle. Workers, it seems, have been producing more per hour but their pay hasn’t kept up as their bosses held onto more of the resulting profit.

Co0mpensation and Productivity 1950-2016

A big part of this has been due to offshoring. If you close a factory where the workers make $30 an hour and set up in a place where your new workers make $5, then the $25 difference flows to the bottom line. Other contributors are automation, which is both inexorable and hugely favorable for the guys who own the robots, and the fact that the minimum wage in many states has kept up with neither the true inflation rate nor the increase in free-trade driven corporate earnings.

As EPI’s Josh Bivens puts it:

This 6.8 percentage-point decline in labor’s share of corporate income might not seem like a lot, but if labor’s share had not fallen, employees in the corporate sector would have $535 billion more in their paychecks today. If this amount was spread over the entire labor force (not just corporate sector employees) this would translate into a $3,770 raise for each worker.

For stock market investors, the scary thing about this imbalance between capital and labor is that it’s only temporary. As the details and magnitude of the scam have been exposed, the political tide has shifted. At the national level, fed-up US workers have installed an anti-free trade administration that is already tilting the playing field towards domestic workers. At the state and local level, calls for a higher minimum wage are being heard and acted upon. A major French party has even nominated a presidential candidate who wants to tax robots.

So it’s safe to assume that the above charts will develop serious inflection points going forward, as a rising share of profits flow to the nether regions of the org chart and investors respond by lowering the value they place on a given dollar of corporate revenues.

As Hussman notes, just a return to 1990s valuation levels would cut the average US stock in half.

 

Back to homepage

Leave a comment

Leave a comment