• 2 hours Is This The World’s First Truly Democratic Stock Exchange?
  • 5 hours India’s Wealthiest Set To Hold $23 Trillion By 2028
  • 8 hours First Quarter Profits Slip For World's Top Oil Companies
  • 10 hours The Yuan May Be China's Biggest Weakness
  • 1 day Hedge Funds Having A Banner Year
  • 1 day Disney Heiress Asks “Is There Such A Thing As Too Much?”
  • 1 day BHP Turns Bullish On EVs
  • 1 day Investors Turn Bullish On America’s Nuclear Decommissioning Business
  • 2 days The $90M Inflatable Rabbit Redefining Modern Art
  • 2 days Huawei’s Fate In The Air
  • 2 days Tesla Slashes Prices Again
  • 2 days The Modern History Of Financial Entropy
  • 3 days Italy’s Central Bank Embraces Sustainable Investing
  • 3 days Trump Lifts Metals Tariffs To Cool Simmering Trade War
  • 3 days Researchers Push To Limit Space Mining
  • 3 days Could China Start Dumping U.S. Treasury Bonds?
  • 4 days Is Winter Coming For HBO?
  • 4 days Rise Of EVs Signals Peak Gasoline
  • 5 days Jeff Bezos Doubles Down On Space Colonization Ambitions
  • 5 days Gold Mining Stocks Stuck In Limbo
Market Sentiment At Its Lowest In 10 Months

Market Sentiment At Its Lowest In 10 Months

Stocks sold off last week…

How Millennials Are Reshaping Real Estate

How Millennials Are Reshaping Real Estate

The real estate market is…

Strong U.S. Dollar Weighs On Blue Chip Earnings

Strong U.S. Dollar Weighs On Blue Chip Earnings

Earnings season is well underway,…

  1. Home
  2. Markets
  3. Other

Consumer Confidence Strongest Since December 2000: A Strong Contrarian Indicator?

Consumer Sentiment and Consumer Confidence are similar measures by two different organizations. The former is from the University of Michigan, the latter is by the Conference Board.

Consumer Confidence soared to 125.6 in March, up from 116.1 in February. This is the strongest reading in over 16 years.

Bloomberg Econoday cites the strength in both the current index and the expectations index, emphasis mine.


It was two cycles ago that the consumer confidence index has been this high, at 125.6 in March for the strongest reading since December 2000. At 113.8, the expectations component hasn't been this high since September 2000. The present situation component is at 143.1 for its best reading since August 2001 which was just at the end of the 1991 to 2001 economic cycle.

Subcomponents in the present situation are closely watched for indications on the monthly employment report and today's results are very positive. Fewer, at 19.5 vs 19.9 percent, say jobs are hard to get this month and many more, at 31.7 vs February's 26.9 percent, say jobs are plentiful.

A key reading on the expectations side is income, and here too the results are very positive. More this month, at 21.5 vs 19.2 percent, see their income increasing over the next six months and fewer, at only 7.0 vs 8.1 percent, see their income declining.

Buying plans are mixed with autos up but homes down. A negative in the report is a 2 tenths decline in 12-month inflation expectations to only 4.6 percent which is very low for this reading.

Consumers are extremely upbeat right now though the lack of inflation expectations doesn't quite fit. What else doesn't fit is actual consumer spending which has failed to match the strength underway in confidence. Watch on Friday for the consumer sentiment report which breaks down what it describes as unprecedented polarization in its sample between the optimism of Republicans and the pessimism of Democrats.

Questioning the Numbers

The conference board surveys 3,000 people every month.

Is 3,000 a sufficiently large number to map out confidence levels for the entire nation? I will ask Salil Mehta at Statistical Ideas for feedback on that question.

The more pertinent question, which I have discussed before, is: Does consumer confidence track spending?

That's a widely held belief. And every month Econoday reinforces that belief with this statement: "While the level of consumer confidence is associated with consumer spending, the two do not move in tandem each and every month."

Consumer Sentiment Snake Oil

On March 21, I wrote Consumer Sentiment Statistical Noise: Modern Day Snake Oil.

The charts I posted compared "consumer sentiment" by the University of Michigan, not "consumer confidence" by the conference board. The latter charges for its information. What follows is a set of charts from the preceding link.

Consumer Sentiment vs. Retail Sales

Consumer Sentiment vs. Retail Sales

As you can see, retail sales keep marching higher and higher, slowing or stalling only in recessions. This is not an accurate comparison because the population is constantly growing.

I will adjust the chart in a moment, but first, let's consider the population effect.

Total US Population

Total US Population

US Population Percent Change From Year Ago

US Population Percent Change From Year Ago

The impact of population growth is one of the factors that affect sales growth.

But age itself is a factor. The spending habits and needs of someone of age 3 are far different from someone age 13, 23, 43, 63, or 83.

Nonetheless, we can make a crude adjustment to retail sales by factoring in population changes.

Sentiment vs Retail Sales Percent Change Minus Population Percent Change

Sentiment vs Retail Sales Percent Change Minus Population Percent Change

If that chart suggests anything, I sure don't know what, other than volatility in sentiment is far bigger than volatility in retail sales.

Let's adjust sentiment volatility by a factor of six to see if that helps.

Sentiment/6 vs Retail Sales Percent Change Minus Population Percent Change

Sentiment/6 vs Retail Sales Percent Change Minus Population Percent Change

That chart looks like statistical noise. Sometimes the directions match sometimes they don't. Perhaps month-to-month correlations are simply too frequent.

Population Adjusted Retail Sales vs Consumer Sentiment Percent Change From Year Ago

Population Adjusted Retail Sales vs Consumer Sentiment Percent Change From Year Ago

Let's hone in on that for an amusing look.

Population Adjusted Retail Sales vs Consumer Sentiment Percent Change From Year Ago - Detail

Population Adjusted Retail Sales vs Consumer Sentiment Percent Change From Year Ago - Detail

Modern Day Snake Oil

I was discussing economic indicators with Pater Tenebrarum at the Acting Man Blog a couple of days ago. He pinged me with the correct takeaway.

Economic forecasting is not a science, and it is actually not the task of economic science to make forecasts (contrary to what is commonly asserted). Forecasting is akin to the task of the historian. Mises called speculators "historians of the future".

Economic laws only play a role insofar as they can be used as constraints for a forecast. The problem is that all these models simply look at the data of economic history, at statistical series that always turn tail "unexpectedly", driven by human action.

All these mathematical models are complete humbug. It is modern-day snake oil.

Politics vs Sentiment

The above charts are sufficient to prove the snake oiliness of equating sentiment to spending as a predictor of anything.

The story gets even more amusing if you dive into further details of the University of Michigan survey.

The overall level of consumer sentiment remained quite favorable in early March due to renewed strength in current economic conditions as well as the extraordinary influence of partisanship on economic prospects. The Current Economic Conditions component reached its highest level since 2000, largely due to improved personal finances. While current economic conditions were not affected by partisanship, this was not true for the component about future economic prospects: among Democrats, the Expectations Index at 55.3 signaled that a deep recession was imminent, while among Republicans the Index at 122.4 indicated a new era of robust economic growth was ahead. Interestingly, those who self-identified as Independents had an Expectations Index of 88.3, which was nearly equal to the midpoint of the partisan difference. Importantly, there was no moderation in these extreme views from last month, with the maintenance of the partisan divide fueled by selective attention to economic news, with Democrats more frequently reporting unfavorable developments and Republicans more frequently hearing of favorable changes. Overall, the sentiment data has been characterized by rising optimism as well as by rising uncertainty due to the partisan divide. Optimism promotes discretionary spending, and uncertainty makes consumers more cautious spenders. This combination will result in uneven spending gains over time and across products.

Look Ahead Index of Sentiment

  • Democrats: 55.3 Supposedly this signals "a deep recession is imminent."
  • Republicans: 122.4 Supposedly this indicates "a new era of robust economic growth is ahead."
  • Independents: 88.3 That is "nearly equal to the midpoint of the partisan difference."

Consumer sentiment suggests a deep recession within a new era of economic growth in which nothing much at all happens. Economists believe consumer spending will follow.

What Does Sentiment Match?

John Hussman provided the chart that got me diving into the above results. Once again, here it is:

Consumer Confidence vs. S&P 500

Consumer Confidence vs. S&P 500

How Contrarian Is Such Confidence?

Belief in these measures of confidence and sentiment is high but the charts show such faith is seriously misplaced.

Moreover, please note that sentiment peaked just before the 2001 recession. It would be a fitting irony if the same happened again.

Why shouldn't that be the case again?

Hussman Tweeted, and I strongly agree, "Multi-year highs in consumer confidence are less a sign of forthcoming consumer spending as a sign of forthcoming investor losses."


Back to homepage

Leave a comment

Leave a comment