• 12 hours Trump Signs Executive Order To Protect Private Moon Miners
  • 1 day Renters Are Striking As COVID Reshapes Real Estate
  • 2 days Nothing Can Stop The Tesla Boom
  • 2 days 9 Ways The Lockdown Is Playing Out Around The World
  • 2 days WeWork Sues SoftBank For Withdrawing $3 Billion Insider Payoff
  • 3 days Solving Transportation’s Biggest Problem
  • 3 days Big Banks Could Win Big On Fed Small Business Bailout
  • 3 days Trump Increases Pressure On Venezuela
  • 4 days Researchers Create Organic Battery
  • 4 days Gold Is Still A Safe Haven, But Not Very Alluring
  • 4 days China Is Buying Up Billions Of Barrels Of Cheap Crude Oil
  • 5 days Are Gold Stocks Going To Bounce Back?
  • 5 days The Politics Of A Pandemic
  • 7 days What Does CHina’s EV Slowdown Mean For The Battery Metals Sector?
  • 7 days COVID Report Cards Will Brand Businesses Forever
  • 7 days Trump Tweet Sends Oil Soaring 25%
  • 8 days Why The Coronavirus Economic Crash Is Worse Than You Think
  • 9 days Is A Global Currency Necessary?
  • 9 days America Has Shed 500,000 Millionaires Since The Coronavirus Lockdown Began
  • 9 days Trump Wants Another $2 Trillion Economic Intervention
How The Ultra-Wealthy Are Using Art To Dodge Taxes

How The Ultra-Wealthy Are Using Art To Dodge Taxes

More freeports open around the…

What's Behind The Global EV Sales Slowdown?

What's Behind The Global EV Sales Slowdown?

An economic slowdown in many…

Robert Prechter

Robert Prechter

Robert Prechter, Jr., is a social theorist and market analyst. He is president of Elliott Wave International, a forecasting firm servicing institutional and private investors…

Contact Author

  1. Home
  2. Markets
  3. Other

The Myth of Shocks

An Excerpt from Chapter 1 of The Socionomic Theory of Finance

Few people find a new theory accessible until they first see errors in the old way of thinking. Part I of this book challenges the universally accepted paradigm under which humans' rational reactions to exogenous (external, or externally generated) causes purportedly account for financial market behavior. The current chapter explores whether dramatic news events affect financial markets.


Testing Financial-Market Reaction under Perfect Conditions

In the physical world of mechanics, action is followed by reaction. When a bat strikes a ball, the ball changes course.

Most financial analysts, economists, historians, sociologists and futurists believe that society works the same way. They typically say, "Because so-and-so has happened, it will cause such-and-such reaction." This mechanics paradigm is ubiquitous in financial commentary. The news headlines in Figure 1 reflect what economists tell reporters: Good economic news makes the stock market go up; bad economic news makes it go down. But is it true?

Market News
Figure 1

In the second half of the 1990s, a popular book made a case for buying and holding stocks forever. In March 2004, after several terrorist attacks had occurred, the author told a reporter, "Clearly, the risk of terror is the major reason why the markets have come down. We can't quantify these risks; it's not like flipping a coin and knowing your odds are 50-50 that an attack won't occur."

In other words, he accepts the mechanics paradigm of exogenous cause and effect with respect to the stock market but says he cannot predict a major cause part of the equation. The first question is, if one cannot predict causes, then how can one write a book predicting effects? A second question is far more important: Is there any evidence that dramatic news events that make headlines, including terrorist attacks, political events, wars, natural disasters and other crises, are causal to stock market movement?

Suppose the devil were to offer you historic news a day in advance, no strings attached. "What's more," he says, "you can hold a position in the stock market for as little as a single trading day after the event or as long as you like." It sounds foolproof, so you accept.

His first offer: "The president will be assassinated tomorrow." You can't believe it. You are the only person in the world who knows it's going to happen.

The devil transports you back to November 22, 1963. You quickly take a short position in the stock market in order to profit when prices fall on the bad news you know is coming. Do you make money?

 


To continue reading, follow this link to elliottwave.com

This article was syndicated by Elliott Wave International and was originally published under the headline The Myth of Shocks. EWI is the world's largest market forecasting firm. Its staff of full-time analysts led by Chartered Market Technician Robert Prechter provides 24-hour-a-day market analysis to institutional and private investors around the world.

 

Back to homepage

Leave a comment

Leave a comment