• 6 hours $120,000 Banana Gets Eaten At Art Basel
  • 1 day The Fastest Growing Energy Sectors Of 2019
  • 2 days How To Spy On Yourself: The Doorbell To End Civil Liberties
  • 3 days Analyst Predicts Tesla Stock Will Soar To $500
  • 4 days Australian Billionaire To Invest In $88 Million Struggling Solar Project
  • 5 days Twitter-Shaming: The Biggest Threat To Any Business
  • 5 days Canada Looks To Become A Major Source For Critical Minerals
  • 5 days Hedge Funds Are Piling Into This Key Commodity
  • 7 days Trade Deal Not Likely Before Christmas 2020
  • 7 days America's $16 Trillion Debt Bubble Is About To Burst
  • 8 days Black Friday Breaks Online Shopping Records
  • 8 days Tesla's Biggest Competitor Is Hiding In Plain Sight
  • 9 days Are Celebrities Good Or Bad For Cannabis Stocks?
  • 10 days Venezuela’s Crisis Continues As Maduro Spends $5 Billion On Oil Deals
  • 11 days Elon Musk Claims 250,000 Orders For Cybertruck
  • 12 days How To Survive Thanksgiving Politics With Cannabis Gravy
  • 13 days The Fragility Of Monetary Policy
  • 14 days 5 Oligopoly Stock Picks For Your 2020 Portfolio
  • 14 days $7 Trillion In Unfunded U.S. Pensions As Domestic Debt Hits A Record High
  • 15 days Retail Is Alive And Well, But Only For The Rich
Another Retail Giant Bites The Dust

Another Retail Giant Bites The Dust

Forever 21 filed for Chapter…

Is The Bull Market On Its Last Legs?

Is The Bull Market On Its Last Legs?

This aging bull market may…

Zombie Foreclosures On The Rise In The U.S.

Zombie Foreclosures On The Rise In The U.S.

During the quarter there were…

John Rubino

John Rubino

John Rubino edits DollarCollapse.com and has authored or co-authored five books, including The Money Bubble: What To Do Before It Pops, Clean Money: Picking Winners…

Contact Author

  1. Home
  2. Markets
  3. Other

Misunderstanding GDXJ: Why It's Actually Great News For Junior Miners

Something extraordinarily good for junior precious metals miners just happened. But for some reason it's being misinterpreted as a bad thing. Here's the general story:

A Small-Cap Gold Mining ETF Streaks Lower As Big Index Change Looms

(Investors.com) – Mining stocks blazed a bright trail of returns since the start of 2016 as gold saw a renaissance and geopolitical uncertainties rose. That popularity has been double-edged for one gold mining ETF, which is now streaking lower.

VanEck Vectors Junior Gold Miners (GDXJ) is set for a major revamp of the underlying index, which will broaden the exchange traded fund's market-cap range and raise the average size of its stocks.

Torrid asset growth has led to concerns that GDXJ is too big for its index, with massive stakes in some stock holdings making the overhaul necessary, as ETF.com first reported.

For investors in this popular and heavily traded ETF, the changes may mean less small-cap exposure than they have come to expect.

Under the new indexing method, the ETF's largest company by market cap could be $2.9 billion -- vs. $1.8 billion under the current method -- putting it over the traditional $2.5 billion limit for small caps.

The index change is set to take effect June 17, but the Junior Gold Miners ETF already has started buying stocks not in the underlying index.

The new names include Alamos Gold (AGI), B2Gold (BTG), Iamgold (IAG), Pretium Resources (PVG), Real Gold Mining and Patagonia Gold, besides a hefty stake in its large-cap sibling, VanEck Vectors Gold Miners (GDX).

They now constitute the ETF's top holdings and account for more than a quarter of portfolio assets combined.

Asset Haul
Assets in GDXJ have ballooned 270% from $1.3 billion at the start of 2016, making it a $5 billion ETF “attempting to invest in (an approximately) 30 billion gold universe,” as one analyst told ETF.com. As money flowed in, GDXJ ended up owning more than 18% of some Canadian stocks.

That called into question its adherence to diversification rules.

Both tax and securities laws provide diversification standards for funds registered under the Investment Company Act. They limit, in part, the amount of a company's outstanding shares that a fund may own -- no more than 10%, in the case of securities law.

When this story broke, a couple of things happened. First, GDXJ plunged as investors concluded that it's now a lot less exciting.

VanEck Vectors Junior Gold Miners Daily Chart

Second, the stocks it was forced to sell to get back below statutory ownership limits plunged. Here's Klondex Mines, a representative example:

Klondex Mines Daily Chart

This has understandably dismayed the owners of these shares, and led to a lot of handwringing about dark times for junior miners.

But the truth is very different. To understand why, pretend you're running a company that creates and markets ETFs. From your point of view, is the GDXJ saga a cautionary tale of a mismanaged fund? Nope. What you see is massive investor interest in a segment where you're not represented. Then you look at the precious metals ETFs now on the market (the following chart is from the above investors.com article) and notice that GDXJ is the only one focused on junior gold miners.

Best Precious Metal ETF's

You also notice that the best performing ETF on the list holds junior silver miners. Since your job is to attract investors' money, how do you respond to this multi-billion-dollar unfilled need? You fill it, of course, by bringing out copycat funds.

In years to come there will be a wave of GDXJ and SILJ wanna-be ETFs. They'll be smaller than the incumbent funds so initially at least won't have to worry about owing too much of any one stock. But in the aggregate they'll end up being bigger than GDXJ, which means they'll swamp the junior mining sector -- which is, as noted above, tiny and illiquid.

The result: a serious, ongoing tailwind for a sector that's already seeing increased interest from both investors and speculators. Going forward, the juniors will be the hottest part of what should be a very hot precious metals market.

 

Back to homepage

Leave a comment

Leave a comment