• 9 hours Why Silicon Valley Is Moving To Toronto
  • 13 hours Hong Kong Residents Are Fleeing To Taiwan At A Record Pace
  • 16 hours Trickle Down Tax Cuts Aren't Helping Bolster GDP Growth
  • 1 day Wealth Gap Widens Between Baby Boomers And Millennials
  • 1 day How Investors Are Playing Uncertain Markets
  • 2 days Demand For Cash Is On The Rise
  • 2 days The Best Way To Ride The Gold Rally
  • 3 days Corn Industry Reeling After Shocking Ethanol Decision
  • 3 days Gold Miners Eye Further Upside
  • 4 days Alibaba Exec Sets Record With $3.5 Billion Brooklyn Nets Purchase
  • 4 days Smart Contracts: The Tech Reshaping Entire Industries
  • 5 days Protests Threaten $5 Billion Peruvian Copper Mine
  • 5 days Why Wealthy Kids Are Getting Into College For Free
  • 6 days Is Is Too Late To Get Into The New Gold Boom?
  • 6 days Solar Tech Breakthroughs Spark Surge In Adoption
  • 6 days These Rare Stones Are About To Become Priceless
  • 7 days Why Silver Miners Aren’t Living Up To Expectations
  • 7 days WeWork Reveals Huge Losses Ahead Of IPO
  • 7 days American Education Continues To Fall Behind China
  • 8 days EV Sector Needs 250% More Of This Metal By 2030 Just For Charging Stations
The Problem With Modern Monetary Theory

The Problem With Modern Monetary Theory

Modern monetary theory has been…

Billionaires Are Pushing Art To New Limits

Billionaires Are Pushing Art To New Limits

Welcome to Art Basel: The…

Andrew Smithers

Andrew Smithers

Andrew Smithers, founder of Smithers & Co., is also columnist for London's Evening Standard and the Tokyo Nikkei Kinnyu Shimbon's Market Eye, and is regularly…

Contact Author

  1. Home
  2. Markets
  3. Other

Independence For Scotland

The most interesting feature of the Scottish elections was the pledge by the Nationalists to cut business taxes. It shows why Scotland and England should both benefit from an independent Scotland.

Representing only 10% of the UK's population, Scotland has long suffered from a dependency culture. While this was dominant, the central aim of politics was to get as much money as possible out of England, either through a heavily biased allocation of expenditure or by claiming exclusive rights to oil revenues.

Whichever route was preferred, it was a world away from the self-help philosophy of Samuel Smiles, which seems, as much for countries as for individuals, to be the long-term winner in terms of economic success. Over the centuries, the achievements of Venice, Holland, Britain, Hong Kong and Japan, compared with the Argentine or Venezuela, suggest that it is an economic advantage to have poor natural resources. This has been so well illustrated in recent years that the debilitating effect of easy wealth on the economies of the Middle East has become known as the curse of oil.

At first, oil enabled the Scottish National Party ("SNP") to call for independence while pandering to a dependency culture. But as hopes fade about the long-term potential of Scottish waters, the clash between independence and dependence has become too blinding to ignore. From being to the left of Labour, the SNP seems to be starting on the long road to Thatcherism.

The current trend towards economic realism is generally attributed to the economist Andrew Wilson, who was previously at the Scottish Office and the Royal Bank of Scotland. He is advocating a cut in business rates and in corporate taxes, in order to encourage companies to "return to Scotland."

Such measures are opposed by Gordon Brown, who has, therefore, been attacked by the SNP for advocating tax-competition within the European Union, while denying it within the British one. The SNP's case is impeccable, but Gordon Brown's dislike of Scottish independence is not likely to depend on economic logic. He stands for a Scottish seat and may not be anxious to give up the world stage provided by Westminster and G7 meetings for the more parochial pleasures of Edinburgh.

While the SNP are to be congratulated on the speed with which they seem to be accepting the economic logic of independence, they run a big risk of leaving their supporters behind. A Thatcherite Scotland is the sensible and natural result of independence. It is not, however, the most likely route to it.

Back to homepage

Leave a comment

Leave a comment