The Golden Ratio and Fibonacci Modelling Applied to the S&P 500

By: Captain Hook | Mon, Jul 14, 2003
Print Email

Well, here we are again, about to look at some sticky numbers that apply to what has become the grandest mass mania phenomenon ever experienced by mankind, the obsession with financial markets. This essay will focus on examining past inter-market relationships as it pertains to the S&P 500 (SPX) and CBOE Volatility Index (VIX) in the endeavour to construct a model from which the rhythmic signatures of co-relations these markets produce, can be used to forecast price extremity targets and trend changes. The primary thrust of this piece then, is the study of the S&P 500 in an effort to identify progression and regression coefficient factors based on Fibonacci principles to help us understand and trade the beast, based on it's 'harmonic signature'.

In an effort to be expedient, I will not delve into the entire background base of knowledge one should possess about Fibonacci's theories and principles necessary for you to be able to fully enjoy the scope of this discussion. Instead, I would encourage you to refer to my previous paper that deals with this same exercise which pertains specifically to the precious metals complex, attached below, in order to familiarize yourself with the basics surrounding the principles we will employ in this treatise, as well. Although you have no reason to think the model constructs that were arrived at in my previous work regarding Fibonacci's principles applied to the precious metals markets could apply directly, and in proportion, to what could be perceived as unrelated markets, but I can assure you, they do.

The first task at hand is to formulate a basic construct for the model we will employ for this exercise. In doing so, we will establish a base from which to gauge our observations, in order to refine the model into a functional predictive tool. In the case of the relationship between the SPX and VIX, it makes a lot of sense to first look at averaged outcomes, or the 'mean' values of the ratio between the two, in order to help establish the trend, dimension range, and volatility characteristics, as it pertains to values and time. i.e. the 'harmonic signature'. Thus, the first element we will examine is the 'mean' in the intermediate trend sequences of the VIX / SPX ratio to see if there is an identifiable harmonic signature that we can formulate into progression and regression coefficient factors. (See Figure 1)

Figure 1

As one can observe above, the last completed progression sequence mean value was .04, and it began the move from .02, with the first sequence originating at .01 and progressing to .02. As a base then, we can conclude that this relationship is progressing at a coefficient factor of "2", which has statistically proven to be the Phi within the relationship, in terms of defining the progression sequences. Although this exercise possesses limited utility in projecting value extremes by itself, it does establish the basis of our model, from which we can now build on to accomplish primary objective behind constructing this model, which is to formulate a reasonably accurate predictive tool to identify extreme values likely to be printed in the VIX and SPX. So, what is the important information we should take away from the above chart then?

If you read my previous essay attached above, you know that constructing a model of this sort requires not only identifying the progression sequences, but also delineating the harmonic rhythm of the corrective phases, as well. The objective in doing so is to identify the corrective coefficient factor, in order to be able to project likely regression impulses into the future, within the overall harmonic signature prevalent in the model. This corrective coefficient factor is labelled phi, and once identified, represents the expected corrective impulse experienced after a progression sequence is completed, within the overall trend. It should be noted that the trend for the SPX is down, but the trend for the VIX/SPX ratio is higher.

Unlike the outcome in my previous essay using this model, the identification of Phi/phi as it pertains to the VIX / SPX ratio is not going to be quite so easy as it pertains to the extreme values involved. This makes the utility of using mean values as a predictive tool essentially insignificant on a stand alone basis, with regard to aiding investors in identifying swing points, however it does give a base model to work from.

Now that we have a base model from which to work, it's time to turn up the volume, and take a more precise look at just what is going on inside of the VIX/SPX ratio relationship. More specifically, can we apply the progression and regression coefficients identified using mean values to the extremes experienced at intermediate turn points? In one word, the answer is "yes". But it's going to take a bit of work to fully understand just how the identified Phi/phi coefficients should be applied. In order to come to this understanding, it is necessary to examine the S&P 500's trading characteristics in isolation, to see just what has happened since it has topped, and is now in a significant corrective sequence. (See Figure 2)

Figure 2

Above, you have a snapshot of the big picture in terms of where we are in the S&P 500's corrective sequence, including what I consider to be the correct Elliott Wave count. As you can see, as far as the big picture is concerned, thus far the SPX has travelled off of its highs a full 50% of the index's total point value and retraced less than the standard 38.2% Fibonacci measure of the full sequence. This fact should be quite disturbing to the bulls, as I believe the market has now topped. So the question then arises, 'does the 50% retrace of the index's total point value constitute a completion of the corrective sequence for the SPX?' Again, in one word, I believe the answer is "no". And here's why.

If you break the corrective sequence down into it's component parts based on the wave structure of the aggregate move, you actually get quite a different picture, one that conforms to our model exactly, in terms of the harmonic signature the progression and regression coefficients (Phi/phi) do well to define. When we look at the parameters associated with the volatility characteristics of Wave A down in isolation, it becomes apparent that the SPX is indeed vexing within the identified signature. (See Figure 3)

Figure 3

Notice in the above chart that the phi retracement was exactly 50% of the initial impulse down labelled Wave A. Although it may be difficult to ascertain on first glance, the above chart is based on closing prices, as the purpose of this delineation is to show that each of the progression sequences downward so far are characterized by two approximate equal impulses, which can be defined using the Phi coefficient of 2, in that the next impulse lower from the starting point of Wave A is a doubling of the first impulse down from the top. (See Figure 4)

Figure 4

There is a clue in the above chart as to what the character of the future trading pattern in the S&P 500 is going to be. While it is true that future gyrations should fall within the base model parameters, episodes of increased volatility will also help form the pattern, as evidenced by the fact Wave D experienced an initial surge to the 61.8% retrace level, which was not present in the first retrace sequence comprising Wave B. And now that we have established that fact, we can progress into some more congruous dimensional measures in order to more exactly enable our model to project likely turn points with a higher degree of accuracy. Volatility seems destined to increase as the SPX progresses into the final leg of this bear market sequence, and we would like to employ an second examination method as a verifier to our base model, in order to strengthen our conclusions regarding likely turn point values and timing. Before we move on however, it seems appropriate at this point to summarize what we have learned in the three charts directly above.

In order to examine the increasing volatility within the overall corrective sequence in which the SPX is currently engaged, it would be appropriate for you to digress for just a moment in order to take a quick glance at Figure 1 once again. Now that you have done this, you will be better able to understand that we are about to pivot into exponential projection mode, as it pertains to identifying likely absolute extreme targets within the coming progression and regression sequences. Within this endeavour, my observations, initially performing a few basic calculations, led me to the conclusion that the 'Golden Ratio', widely defined by Fibinacci aficionados as the factor 1.618 for Phi and .618 for phi, fit the signature perfectly in the context of an anticipated rise in volatility. (See Figure 5)

Figure 5

Within your observations of the above, one should notice that Golden Ratio projection does not exceed the base model Phi progression coefficient (2), rigorously established above, to any large degree. In fact, one has to marvel at the close proximity of the two values derived from completely separate methods of calculation, with each acting as a verifier for the other. Does it matter which method we use then, for further projection calculations?

Based on the degree of the retracement in the VIX/SPX ratio off the highs of it's last progression sequence, it would definitely seem appropriate to continue to monitor the changing complexion of the harmonic rhythm using both methods to see if values vault out of base model parameters, as the extent of the correction fell within the extremes of Fibonacci retracement numbers. (See Figure 6)

Figure 6

As you can see above, the retracement, characterized by a five-wave affair, has gone to the standard extremity of the Fibonacci doctrine, a 78% correction. Any further deterioration past this point would have to caution bearish assumptions concerning the current downtrend in the S&P 500, at least on a temporary basis. However, based on the work we have done here, one can make a very strong case the retracement in VIX/SPX ratio is now complete for the interim, and that although there may be some transitory topping activity in the SPX, we should soon resume the primary bear market established at the turn back in the year 2000. If this does indeed occur, it will be easy to label this next sequence down as Wave E of Primary Wave A, and the targets using the methods derived in Figure 5 may upset a few of the bulls. (See Figure 7)

Figure 7

Although introduced in Figure 5, one should notice the incorporation of time cells into the model, and that these spans have been marking the extremes and turning points quite accurately for not only the bear phase, but for the bull phase, as well. Utilizing the coefficient factors derived in Figure 5, the calculations in Figure 7 demonstrate that the SPX should see a bottom of approximately 585 to 600 in May of 2004, which should correspond to a print of ~ 80 on the VIX. This would be quite a distance from the VIX's current proximity of ~20. (See Figure 8)

Figure 8

Pictorially, and from a symmetrical perspective, the parabolic bowl captures the essence of the move, both in terms to dimension and time, in that we are approximately half way through the present time cell. Based on the above vigorous statistical examination of the SPX's harmonic signature and the overall appearance of the chart below, it would seem likely that the S&P 500 is about to roll over to complete the sequence (cycle). In fortification of this view, one should notice that next May would mark a two thirds retrace of the previous three consecutive 7.5 quarter time cells off the advance from 600 in the SPX. (See Figure 9)

Figure 9

We have now covered quite a bit of material and I have left a lot unsaid for expediency purposes. If one were so inclined there is a very prominent clue in the above material which even today, with the SPX's bear market in it's infancy, would enable you to project it's final nadir and timing using the model constructs. I encourage you to try as an exercise if you are a trader. And if you are an investor looking for a good time to get out of the market, I would be thinking hard on that proposition at present.

One important observation that may not be easily discernable from the above material, is that as the bear market in the S&P 500 progresses, increased volatility will not alter the final trading values that have now been identified by the harmonic signature, only the timing may be altered due to intervention.

In summation, it seems appropriate to list our findings at this time, in order to complete a more readily identifiable picture for you, as follows:

Well, I think that just about covers it, other than to say trading it won't be so easy, as many speculators have already discovered. One must remember that these are long periods of time involved in this process and only proper structure and instrumentation will increase your odds of trading the beast successfully. I believe it is safe to say that most should not partake in these kinds of endeavours, and that only the most skilled and vigilant will enhance their fortunes in the speculation game. If you must however, the above should provide you with an edge and the appropriate perspective to plan your investment strategies well into the future. Speaking of which, I will be sure to return next spring to update the situation and provide you with a roadmap for what to expect as the S&P 500 (markets) make the big turn into Primary Wave B higher.

Good investing,


Captain Hook

Author: Captain Hook

Captain Hook

Treasure Chests is a market timing service specializing in value-based position trading in the precious metals and equity markets with an orientation geared to identifying intermediate-term swing trading opportunities. Specific opportunities are identified utilizing a combination of fundamental, technical, and inter-market analysis. This style of investing has proven very successful for wealthy and sophisticated investors, as it reduces risk and enhances returns when the methodology is applied effectively. Those interested in discovering more about how the strategies described above can enhance your wealth should visit our web site at Treasure Chests.

Disclaimer: The above is a matter of opinion and is not intended as investment advice. Information and analysis above are derived from sources and utilizing methods believed reliable, but we cannot accept responsibility for any trading losses you may incur as a result of this analysis. Comments within the text should not be construed as specific recommendations to buy or sell securities. Individuals should consult with their broker and personal financial advisors before engaging in any trading activities. We are not registered brokers or advisors. Certain statements included herein may constitute "forward-looking statements" with the meaning of certain securities legislative measures. Such forward-looking statements involve known and unknown risks, uncertainties and other factors that may cause the actual results, performance or achievements of the above mentioned companies, and / or industry results, to be materially different from any future results, performance or achievements expressed or implied by such forward-looking statements. Do your own due diligence.

Unless otherwise indicated, all materials on these pages are copyrighted by Inc. No part of these pages, either text or image may be used for any purpose other than personal use. Therefore, reproduction, modification, storage in a retrieval system or retransmission, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical or otherwise, for reasons other than personal use, is strictly prohibited without prior written permission.

Copyright © 2003-2017 Inc. All rights reserved.

All Images, XHTML Renderings, and Source Code Copyright ©