US inflation slid to its lowest level in 44 years amongst fears that Europe's problems will spillover to North America causing a Japanese style deflation which led to a lost decade of growth. A worsening regional debt crisis that began in Dubai then Greece has spread globally, engulfing the global markets causing a worrying replay of the market collapse of 2008 and 2009. The euro has fallen sharply. The spectre of deflation has again cast a darkening shadow over the markets giving central banks yet another excuse to inject more stimulus spending into their economies. The dramatic collapse in the euro makes European goods more competitive and US goods less which raises the risks of a defacto competitive devaluation reminiscent of the Thirties.
Greed and the financial sector are synonymous and Wall Street deserves no small part of the blame for the economy's collapse. But greedy bankers are not the whole story. A dangerous gap of mistrust and incomprehension has opened between investors and financial markets. The 1,000 point plunge ( and recovery) is further evidence that the world's centre of wealth creation has become an out-of-control casino rigged with exotic financial instruments, high frequency trading and huge profits. We believe the "flash crash" was not your every day garden-variety pullback. Instead, it was an overdue recognition that the game of financial musical chairs has stopped as a consequence of too much debt and leverage. To us, the market simply went "no bid".
Too Big to Bailout
A primary cause of concern is that the European trillion dollar rescue raises familiar problems of moral hazard where a group of self-serving, unaccountable individuals are to be made whole as taxpayers are asked once again to foot the costs of greed which contributed to the economic meltdown. In adding to the burden of debt, governments have ratcheted up spending in classic Keynesian fashion to compensate for the spending shortfall. Thus far, spending by government and households have increasingly substituted for consumption from income with consumption from credit with dubious results. And worse, the public debt has become a private burden.
Today the European rescue focuses on the solvency of those who actually guarantee all those debts, a replay of the AIG debt moment. The interconnected relationship between the investment banks and sovereign nations were so intertwined that just the threat of a default raised the risk that the chain reaction would sink the global financial system. The bailout then was really a bailout of the European banking system. And ironically, any future trouble will require an even bigger bailout and even the useful capital of Wall Street. Putting a "Robin Hood" levy on the banking sector's capital was no way to deal with Europe's problems, particularly when they will eventually need that capital. Markets are saying that if we can't trust Lehman Brothers, Goldman, Dubai and now Greece, why should we trust the system? And with so many frauds, charges and deceptions found to be underlying the current financial crisis, no wonder confidence and trust is gone. Gold is a good thing to have.
Just a few weeks ago, the bailout was supposed to buy time but the same lack of discipline in economic policy and fiscal policies is evident. The world is flooded with liquidity, yet liquidity does not equal solvency. It does not repair the structural imbalances that got Greece and others in trouble in the first place. Worse, the next big domino to fall is the UK which has a budgetary deficit of almost 12 percent of GDP and despite a new austerity plan, needs to borrow one pound for every four it spends. The UK reported record deficits in April. Of concern is that while Greece was small enough to be bailed out, investors worry that ominous comparisons can be made with "Triple A" countries like the United Kingdom or even the United States while not too big to fail, are really too big to bailout.
Greece is a Symbol of Sovereign Indebtedness
A chain is only as strong as its weakest link. The myth of the European Union was that the sixteen member economies would eventually converge with a common currency and that the stronger economies would drag along the weakest economies. But it soon became apparent that the inherent structural imbalances, actually diverged as the huge current account of Germany, the area's biggest economy was not offset by the weaker countries such as Greece or Portugal. And now the trillion dollar rescue package monetizes the debt of several weaker European countries as the European Central Bank backstops their debt. The very large size of the European government bailout is indicative of the Keynesian "solution of the day" but does nothing to make them more solvent, particularly the other weakened Club Med members of the Eurozone. The Greek bailout simply piles more debt upon more debt, pushing its debt to GDP ratio to 113 percent with a budgetary deficit at 13.7 percent of GDP. Greece has become a symbol of sovereign indebtedness.
And for the most part, the rescue comes at an extraordinary high price for the European Central Bank which is breaking its own laws from purchasing member's toxic debts, to the pumping of huge amounts of money, to ignoring the risk of high inflation. The introduction of the IMF is a signal that the European Central Bank has not only lost creditability but sovereignty over its own matters.
And elsewhere, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) has calculated that in less than five years, western governments' public debt would have grown by 40 percent from 2007 to an average of 110 percent of GDP, making Greece's problems pale in comparison. At the end of this year, OECD sovereign debt will have exploded by nearly 70 percent from 38 percent of GDP in 2007. According to the Bank of International Settlements (BIS), structural budgetary deficits are now equivalent to 10 percent of GDP, the highest in modern history.
America's Addiction To Debt Looks More Greek
America shares many of the same fiscal problems currently haunting Europe. America is the weakest "Triple A" credit. After decades of living beyond its means, the US has a debt burden heavier than several of the European weak countries. It has the highest budgetary deficit, the most debt and a worsening current account deficit, making it reliant on financing from Asia. The world's largest economy's balance sheet is getting worse every day with a national debt load at $13 trillion or a whopping $117,975 per debt taxpayer. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projects that in the next decade, US cumulative deficits will reach almost $10 trillion, and the federal debt as a percentage of GDP will surpass that of Italy, Greece and most other nations. This year, America's deficit will grow to 11 percent of GDP and the gross public debt will reach 97 percent of GDP next year. Debt to revenue has more than doubled over the past three years and is now over 400 percent according to Moody's Investor Services Inc. Moody's has even recently warned that America's "Triple A" bond rating risks a downgrade unless measures were taken to reduce the projected record budget deficits.
Add the deficits of the states like California and entitlements, the true shortfall grows even larger. After spending a trillion to bailout Wall Street and an imploding housing sector, America needs to borrow more to finance not only current programs, but new programs let alone the refinancing of existing debt loads. And worse, annual interest payments on these borrowings is to exceed domestic discretionary spending. Of course, President Obama could always increase taxes or cut spending but even the CBO has calculated that the burden is so high that balancing the budget is impossible. In 1950, total public spending made up 24 percent of GDP and despite Obama blaming his predecessor, total spending when Bush left office was 35 percent. Today total spending by federal, state and local will top 44 percent this year, adding tens of billions in red ink and i.o.u's.
Bernanke's Printing Press Undermines the Dollar's Role
There is an alternative. Truth is that history suggests a third and likely option. Ben Bernanke, Fed Chairman, once said that the Fed has a marvellous invention for fighting deflation. He said that the "printing press" could "produce as many US dollars as it wishes, at essentially no cost." Those dollars are needed, since the US Treasury has been the major buyer of its own debt. We believe that the US worsening fiscal situation and unlimited money creation increases, the likelihood of a devaluation that would allow America to inflate their way out of their problems and pay back their loans with a currency worth less. It is not deflation to worry about, but inflation.
And while America has become the biggest debtor of the world, the dollar is still favoured as a safe haven currency. Because the dollar remains the world's reserve currency, it allows Washington to borrow cheaply and finance its gargantuan deficits. Unfortunately, the strength of the dollar is not a sign of strong fundamentals in the American economy. The rush to the so-called safety of US government debt is like handing an anchor to a drowning swimmer. And as Mr Bernanke said, he can always print more - or can he? With today's debt load, the US looks more Greek than the Europeans.
Over half of America's outsized indebtedness is owed to others. China and other foreigners continue to hold the bulk of US Treasuries and remain the drivers for demand for US securities. But that debt load undermines the dollar's role as a reserve currency. Europe's problems forced investors to seek other safe haven currencies. Brazil's real is up 27 percent in the past 12 months, even the Russian rouble is up 14 percent and the Canadian dollar is up more than 15 percent. These countries possess abundant natural resources and investors are hedging their dollar bets. From 1987, the dollar fell by 50 percent as part of the Plaza Accord to reduce the US current account deficit, at 3.5 percent of GDP. Today, the US runs the largest current account deficit in the world that is almost twice as big as then. Greece's near default is a clear warning about the clear and present dangers of unsustainable government debt.
The Shadow Banking System, A System-wide Shell Game?
Derivatives dominate trading from mortgages to stock options, to commodities, and currencies becoming the most profitable of activities for Wall Street's giants. Securitization allowed the big banks to collect fees, lend more, and leverage up their balance sheets, without the need for more capital. However, the discipline of the market was subverted by the Fed's bailout two years ago. With government bailouts assured, it is not surprising that the US financial system has seen explosive growth. Even today, the housing sector remains fully reliant on government-backed guarantees of its paper despite the financial meltdown. Government wards, Fannie and Freddie are still the principal backer of these securities bolstered with $136 billion of Fed money but are still losing money with Freddie posting a $10.6 billion loss in the first quarter. The European bailout itself requires the same financial alchemy by the creation of a special purpose entity to issue debt to provide loans to the weaker countries. The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency reported that investment banks generated a record $22.6 billion in derivative trading revenues last year. And despite the failure of Lehman Brothers and Bear Stearns, Wall Street icons like Goldman Sachs have become bigger and remain outside the purview of the government. Those same players have some $1.7 trillion exposure to Europe's weak members. In a déjà vu moment then, the Greek bailout was really another bailout of the big investment banks.
Last month, the markets were transfixed by oil spills, volcanoes and Goldman Sachs. At one time there were reports that Goldman Sachs had helped Greece to hide its public debt through derivative transactions. At the centre of the Security Exchange Commission's (SEC) case against Goldman Sachs is a collateralised debt obligation (CDO) which casts a spotlight on the exotic instruments and the "system-wide shell game" practices that helped devastate the financial system costing taxpayers trillions while delivering billions of profits to a select few.
The fraud charges against Goldman Sachs sheds light on the "shadow banking system". Today, it is still too big for the banks and too big for governments to allow to fail. The simple mechanics of pooling various loans and selling the cash flow to yield-hungry investors has evolved into opaque instruments like discredited credit default swaps (CDS), collateralized debt obligations (CDOs), or COCOs which has spread epidemic-like throughout the financial world. By now, everyone knows that credit default swaps allows investors to bet or hedge the risk that a company or country will not be able to pay its debts. From Goldman Sachs to Greece and even the US, these so-called over-the-counter derivatives or contracts allowed investor to "short" without having to own the underlying securities. And now, Germany has banned speculation on European government bonds with credit-default swaps, causing a short squeeze. However in the United States, legislators watered down their own "Volcker rule" that would have banned banks from proprietary trading for their own account.
Not only has the shape of the market changed radically but so has its players. Today, many of the hedge funds, including commodity-type hedge players are even bigger than the banks. In fact today only one third of all of America's mortgages are on the banks' balance sheets. According to the Investment Company Institute data, in the last fourteen months almost $400 billion moved into US bond funds and bond mutual funds while stock funds gathered less than $12 billion during the same period. While Obama's financial reform was to address some of the needs of the banks, the big hedge and mutual funds remain outside the purview of the Fed and are left untouched. Today some fourteen hedge funds each manage $20 billion or more with industry hedge assets at $1.6 trillion. Indeed, Bear Stearns and Lehman Brother were not even banks. To be sure, the shadow banking system needs fixing but that means more than just the banks. It means mutual funds, it means the hedge funds, and also means those big sovereign funds. America's addiction to debt is a deeper problem than Goldman Sachs' securities problem. And once the oil spill ends, the volcano settles down and the ash clouds disappear, it is the taxpayer who will pay, not for clouded ash or Goldman's transgressions, but for America's addiction to debt.
Gold Is Sound Money
We believe that gold is a beneficiary of the consequences from the massive bailouts, roller coaster markets and over-valued currencies which have eroded trust in the fiscal and monetary credibility of the global financial system. The history of fiat money has been hyperinflation as governments monetize their debts and currencies collapse to a trillionth of their value. In Weimar Germany, the government printed so many marks as the only way to pay for the war reparations causing hyperinflation and the collapse of the economy. Venezuela and Zimbabwe today are experiencing hyperinflation. In the last century there have been 25 episodes of hyperinflation. All were preceded by up to a decade of excess government spending and monetization of debt such as today. One thing was clear then and now, when government's spend more than they bring in and monetize their debts with increased supplies of fiat currency to fill that gap, great countries can go insolvent.
Freed from the discipline that tied currencies to gold under Bretton Woods which ended almost forty years ago, the major economies led by the United States were able to spend, incur big deficits and bailout their economies with unlimited printed fiat money. Since then, we have been moving from crisis to crisis. With regularity, central banks have opened the monetary flood gates, creating ever bigger bubbles that eventually burst. The explosion of US dollars in the wake of America's easy money policy has seen the monetary base skyrocketing to over $2 trillion producing another trillion dollar currency bubble. As the European credit crisis and Wall Street's bailout now clearly shows, unrestrained government spending has consequences.
Almost a trillion dollars and a year and half later, Wall Street's collapse caused a shrinking greenback and gold reached $1000 an ounce. Because the US spends much more than they produce and owes much more than they own, the world is awash with US dollars. Central banks became net buyers of gold for the first time in twenty years. Today the price of gold has hit all time highs as investors seek a safer alternative to currencies clobbered by Europe's financial crisis. Obama's stimulus is coming undone. Gold has reached all-time highs in euros, swiss francs, sterling and even in dollars. Gold by default has once again become a universal safe haven and protector of all currencies. It is both the index of currency fears and a hedge against declining currencies. Gold is accumulated, not consumed and has acted as a medium of exchange for over 5,000 years.
Part of gold's allure is to be all things to all people. It is seen as a store of value when everything else is risky. For thousands of years it was money and when America decoupled the gold standard in 1971, it was relegated as a commodity. However, commodities have emerged as an asset class. Investment demand has increased with hedge funds and ETFs purchasing physical gold in a diversification move from equities and protection from a sinking dollar. Declining mine output, in particular from South Africa is also supporting prices. And, consumption in Asia remains strong. Yet the dynamics of gold differs too from traditional commodity markets. It is the relationship between the world's dominant currency, the dollar and reaction of global central banks to the various bailouts and defaults that makes gold an attractive bet. In the last century, the dollar has lost almost 95 percent of its purchasing power, yet gold has appreciated 13 times. Gold is money, sound money. It is not that gold has done well, rather it is that the dollar has performed poorly in protecting wealth. Gold is the only alternative investment, it is money.
In 2008, gold rose 5.8 percent as a hedge against the collapse of Wall Street despite US consumer prices gaining only 0.1 percent. In 2005, gold rose 18.5 percent as a hedge against dollar volatility. This year the dollar has jumped 11 percent and gold is also up some 11 percent as both are safe haven beneficiaries. While $1250 may seem high today, it is in fact only half of the inflation adjusted price at $2,200 per ounce. Between 1971 and 1980, gold rose nearly 3,000 percent as investors sought protection from inflation and fears of hyperinflation. This time, with so little metal above ground, gold will head higher as too much money chases too few stocks as investors seeks protection from currency depreciation and the consequences of Obama's unprecedented spending spree. Investors face a trifecta of concerns: a mountain of new sovereign debt, casino-like stock markets and a flood of paper currencies. Yet, gold is only up some 370 percent from its low some eleven years ago. We believe gold will hit $2,000 an ounce this year but head even higher next year as investors seek shelter from continued market uncertainty. Inflation will be tomorrow's problem. This bull market is still a calf.
Recommendations
Replacing reserves is the biggest issue for the gold mining industry as many find themselves stuck on the treadmill. While there is no shortage of small deposits in the world, there are few midsize deposits that can justify the billion dollar price tags and time requirement needed to replace the industry's declining profile. For example, American Barrick's multi-billion Cerro Casale project has a rate of return of only 5.5 percent. In addition, while most of the consolidation in the mining industry has occurred, the big companies are left to spinning off smaller assets or to acquiring small deposits in the hopes of expanding these deposits. Goldcorp's acquisition of Eleonore in Quebec, is a good example of how Goldcorp has been expanding its reserves and resources, though output is still two years away. The competition for deposits has escalated with a Chinese state-owned company acquiring a majority stake in the 17 million ounce Las Cristinas deposit leaving Crystallex with a third carried interest.
As gold retests its all time high, there will be more investor attention and pressure for producers to grow their production and reserves. As such we continue to emphasize the mid-cap producers Eldorado Gold, Agnico-Eagle, Centerra and smaller Aurizon because of their growth profile and their ability to organically grow their production and reserves. We expect a competition for development/exploration companies like Detour Lake, Osisko Mines, and East Asia Minerals whose deposits are expected to garner attention from the senior producers. We believe that it is still cheaper to buy ounces on Bay Street. And, given the positive outlook for the price of gold, we believe that the smaller exploration companies will attract increased attention not only from the cash flush producers but also from investors. At long last, we believe that the Street will finance well grounded exploration plays and thus we have profiled the following number of potential "ten baggers".
Aurizon Mines Ltd.
Aurizon is a gold producer whose assets are in the Abitibi region of northwestern Quebec. Aurizon Mines reported a positive quarter as their Casa Berardi mine in Quebec continues to generate profits and sufficient cash flow to develop the 100 percent owned Joanna project. Aurizon has an excellent balance sheet and an attractive exploration/development program. We like the shares here.
East Asia Minerals Corp.
East Asia continues to expand its large MIwah gold project in Aceh province, northern Indonesia. The high sulphidization epithermal project is a major gold discovery and has expanded to more than 10 million ounces of resource outlined so far. While, East Asia believes the main zones are open in all directions, recent drill plans appear to be testing the westerly limits are drilling towards Moon River and Sipopok, to the north of Miwah. East Asia has drilled about 33 holes and plans another 40 odd holes this year with a recent $18 million financing allowing East Asia to fasttrack this program. The addition of a third drill machine, will test the western and northern boundaries of the deposit.
It is our view that this impressive deposit is similar to the volcanic setting of the big Yanacocha system in Peru, which is the second largest mine in the world. Yanacocha is also a large high sulphidisation gold system with numerous clusters covering some 22,000 acres with almost 30 million ounces. East Asia was recently granted title to the 85 percent owned Miwah deposit through an IUP, which gives East Asia three years to complete exploration and under the new Indonesian mining law, can automatically convert its license to a 20 year term with another 20 year renewable period. We continue to recommend the shares as one of the most exciting exploration plays in the last five years. Buy.
Excellon Resources Inc.
Excellon has the highest grade mine in Mexico, with an average grade at 980 gram/tonne with 9 percent lead and 10 percent zinc. Excellon reported a small profit in the first quarter on revenues of $10 million. Excellon shipped 432,000 ounces silver, 2 million pounds of lead, and 2.2 million pounds of zinc during the quarter. Cash costs after by product credits average $5 an ounce silver, and the company expensed $2.2 million on exploration. Excellon released results at the La Platosa which showed an expansion of the southerly mantos and also released initial results at the Miquel Auza program. Excellon is drilling six northwest trending epithermal quartz, sulphide-rich Madera veins which are part of the known Fresnillo trend which produces about 10 percent of Mexico's silver production. Excellon has an ambitious exploration program which could easily develop into company builders.
Meanwhile, Excellon is expanding its production beyond the 1.6 million ounces of annual production and in our opinion could double its output. To date, Excellon has easily replaced reserves and in time is a potential takeover target or indeed acquisitor. Excellon has $8.2 million in cash and is on track to discover the source of the La Platosa carbonate replacement deposit system (CRD). While the Miquel Azua mill is running at 200 tonnes per day, the mill could easily run at double that rate, which would expand production and lower cash costs. We visited Excellon's La Platosa mine and Miquel Auza mill last year. We like the shares here.
Lake Shore Gold Corp.
Lake Shore is bringing three mines into production and should produce 65,000 ounces this year. The underground mine at Timmins Ontario is part of the Bell Creek complex which was refurbished to capacity of 1,500 tonnes per day. Thunder Creek will be brought on next year, which could double Lake Shore's output. Lake Shore has almost 2 million ounces of resources. Hochschild Mining Plc of Peru currently owns 38 percent and we believe they will make a bid for the balance once its standstill expires this November. We believe the shares should be bought here for both the takeover potential and rising production profile.
MAG Silver Corp.
MAG Silver is an advanced high grade silver player that completed the Valdecanas scoping study at its Juanicipo joint venture in the Zacatecas silver district in Mexico. We expect joint venture partner Fresnillo PLC to make another bid for Mag's 44 percent interest which abuts Fresnillo's huge mining complex. The $1 billion project has an IRR of 48.4 percent, 12 year mine life and could produce 14 million ounces of silver annually. MAG Silver has ten other projects in Mexico including the promising Cinco de Mayo moly/gold prospect in northern Chihuahua. Drilling continues with four machines. MAG Silver has a healthy balance sheet with $26 million of cash and is well positioned for the inevitable takeover. Buy.
Rubicon Minerals Corp.
Rubicon is expanding the F2 gold discovery in the heart of the Red Lake district in northwestern Ontario. Drilling results at the 100 percent owned Phoenix property continues to show excellent high grade as the company delineates the north part of the system. Most intersections to date contain more than bonanza-like 10 grams per tonne of gold and the results are part of a huge 158,000 metre drill program. We like Rubicon here as they expand the deposit, making it an ideal takeover tidbit for a company looking for a look-a-like Campbell Red Lake deposit.
St. Andrew Goldfields Ltd.
St. Andrew Goldfield's is a new gold producer with an extensive land package in the Timmins mining district in northwestern Ontario. St. Andrew has pulled off a turnaround led by Jacques Perron who has reopened the Holloway mine and begun production from the nearby Hislop open pit. The company should produce 65,000 ounces this year and expected to produce about 110,000 ounces next year. Now that the royalty issue was settled in its favour, St. Andrew will brings the Holt mine into production, which is adjacent to the Holloway mine. St Andrew finally has cash flow and now, the company has the funds to explore one of the largest land positions in the Timmins mining district. Exploration at Smoke Deep and Deep Thunder zones have been encouraging, which could expand the Holloway reserves and extend mine life. Also St. Andrews has the one million ounce Aquarius project in inventory which has an attractive upside. With a growing production profile, three development projects and almost $200 million of tax pools, St. Andrews is a well placed junior. Buy.
US Gold Corp
Rob McEwen's US Gold continues to expand the promising El Gallo project in Sinaloa state in northwestern Mexico. US Gold has a whopping 500,000 acres in Mexico and the El Gallo silver/gold deposit continues to grow and is open in all direction. We recently visited El Gallo. US Gold is spending $18 million in exploration mostly at El Gallo with a 100,000 metre drill program. US Gold plans to complete a feasibility study next year and the deposit together with nearby Palmarito could be processed at US Gold's Majistral plant which is currently on care and maintenance. Preliminary bottle and column met tests show good recoveries. Meanwhile, drilling and exploration work continues at the company's other gold prospects in Nevada. In our view US Gold has an excellent balance sheet and an excellent pipeline of projects which have exceptional potential to add value. Buy
Company Name | Trading Symbol | *Exchange | Disclosure code |
Eldorado | ELD | T | 1 |
Agnico-Eagle Mines | AEM | T | - |
Rubicon | RMX | T | 1 |
Mag Silver | MAG | T | 1 |
East Asia Minerals | EAS | V | 1,8 |
Aurizon | ARZ | T | 1 |
Lake Shore Gold | LSG | T | 1 |
Excellon | EXN | T | 1,5,6,8 |
US Gold | UXG | T | 1 |
St. Andrews Gold | SAS | T | 1 |
Centerra | CG | T | 1 |