• 14 hours Rio Tinto To Spend $1 Billion To Reduce Its Carbon Footprint
  • 1 day The Ultra-Wealthy Lost $140 Billion In One Day
  • 2 days Three Energy Casualties In The Coronavirus Crisis
  • 3 days Markets Crumble As Coronavirus Panic Peaks
  • 3 days Cobalt May Be The Key To Clean Hydrogen Fuel
  • 5 days How Taxpayers Are Bankrolling The EV Revolution
  • 6 days The Coronavirus Is Crushing China’s Car Market
  • 7 days Fighting For Survival In The Streaming War
  • 7 days Want A Job? Forget About A Bachelor’s Degree
  • 8 days Another Major Car Maker Is Backing Hydrogen
  • 8 days Are Americans Finally Sold On Soccer?
  • 9 days Is The Tech Bubble About To Burst?
  • 9 days Coronavirus Could Cost Tourism Industry $80 Billion
  • 10 days What Web Traffic Trends Can Tell Us About The World
  • 10 days Miners Face Greater Headwinds
  • 11 days Boris Johnson Proposes Billion Dollar Bridge To Northern Ireland
  • 12 days Goldman Slashes Oil Price Forecast By $10
  • 13 days Tesla Raises $2 Billion In Share Selloff
  • 13 days What The T-Mobile Takeover Of Sprint Really Means For Markets
  • 14 days The U.S. Has Charged Huawei With Racketeering And Conspiracy
Tesla Reopens Chinese Factory After Coronavirus Scare

Tesla Reopens Chinese Factory After Coronavirus Scare

Tesla’s Gigafactory in Shanghai has…

SUV Sales Continue To Soar

SUV Sales Continue To Soar

Global SUV and truck sales…

Damir Kaletovic

Damir Kaletovic

Writer, Safehaven.com

Damir Kaletovic is an award-winning investigative journalist, documentary filmmaker and expert on Southeastern Europe whose work appears on behalf of Safehaven.com.

Contact Author

  1. Home
  2. News
  3. Breaking News

Controversial European Internet Law Rejected

EU

When the European Parliament rejected a major EU copyright law proposal last week, it was a significant victory for big tech companies, and possibly—as some argue—internet freedom as a whole, or at least the freedom to meme virally.

The whole thing was about trying to do the impossible: make sure content creators are paid for everything everyone uses in this hyper-connected world.

The European Parliament will take another crack at copyright laws in September, but tech giants are chalking this up to a defeat for the likes of (among many others) Beatles legend Paul McCartney, who was one of the biggest lobbying forces behind the proposed law.

It had also earned the support of publishers such as Agence France Press (AFP) at a time when these traditional media outlets are being crushed by newcomers offering free online news. In the same vein, artists are losing out to the digital free-for-all, while tech giants are capitalizing on the same.

But tradition, in this case, is going to have to come up with a different game plan or be swallowed alive.

The proposed law was designed to give publishers and content creators a life-line for revenues lost to the digital era due to lack of protection for legally copyrighted material regurgitated by tech giants, including Google’s Youtube and Facebook.

The biggest sticking point was the part of the law that would have made online platforms liable for spinning material by users that was under copyright. In other words, if a Youtuber used something that was copyrighted, Google would be held legally liable.

Opponents coming out on the tech side of this debate have sounded the alarm bells over what would ultimately turn out to be censorship of the internet, while others, like McCartney, argue that the free-for-fall is jeopardizing the music “ecosystem”.

In an open letter to European Parliament ahead of the vote, McCartney said: “We need an Internet that is fair and sustainable for all. But today some User Upload Content platforms refuse to compensate artists and all music creators fairly for their work, while they exploit it for their own profit. The value gap is that gulf between value these platforms derive from that music and the value they pay creators.” Related: How Will Gold Respond To Escalating Tariff Wars?

Tech giants insist that this is a victory for democracy, and that a ‘yes’ vote in European Parliament would have meant the death of creativity.

European MP Julia Reda, from the German Pirate Party, chimed in on the proposed law, saying “It’s illusory to believe that all platforms will just take out licenses from all news sources for all EU countries. That’s a near-impossible feat. Those affected the worst will be people living in small member states and those wanting to link to less well-known sources—discriminating people based on their country and harming media pluralism.”

What it comes down to is this: Who would we rather have control the media—media outlets or tech giants?

It’s a question that doesn’t even need to be answered because the lobbying power will win this regardless, and that means the tech giants.

All told, according to Bloomberg, Google threw $36 million at this European copyright mosquito—and it was only one of the tech giants in play.

By Damir Kaletovic for Safehaven.com

More Top Reads From Safehaven.com:

Back to homepage

Leave a comment

Leave a comment