"No warning can save people determined to grow suddently rich" - Lord Overstone

  • 1 hour Who Will Pay For Trump's $60 Billion China Tariffs?
  • 17 hours Vladimir Putin’s Mysterious Fortune
  • 18 hours Cryptos Resist Social Media Crackdown
  • 19 hours The Death Of Dodd-Frank
  • 20 hours Bitcoin Bounces Back Ahead Of G20 Meeting
  • 21 hours Trump's Trade War Nears Boiling Point
  • 22 hours Will April Be A Turning Point For Precious Metals?
  • 24 hours Economic Pressures Weigh On Banks And Borrowers
  • 1 day U.S. Political Uncertainty Keeps Stock Markets On Edge
  • 2 days Gold: The Religion Of Currency
  • 3 days Economists Polarized On Trump’s Tariff Plan
  • 4 days Why Are Investors Overlooking Gold Stocks?
  • 4 days The App That Democratized Trading Is Now Worth $5B
  • 4 days Super-Cycles: Why Gold Is Set For A Breakout
  • 4 days U.S. Sanctions Russia For Election Meddling And Cyberattacks
  • 4 days Snap Shares Tank Over ‘Slap Rihanna’ Campaign
  • 4 days How Low Can Bitcoin Go?
  • 4 days Amazon’s Japan HQ Raided In Anti-Monopoly Push
  • 4 days Is Barrick Gold Close To Finding A Bottom?
  • 5 days Morgan Stanley’s Top 10 Short-Term Stock Picks
Snap Shares Tank Over ‘Slap Rihanna’ Campaign

Snap Shares Tank Over ‘Slap Rihanna’ Campaign

Snapchat’s share prices tumbled after…

Alibaba Soars On Reports Of China Listing

Alibaba Soars On Reports Of China Listing

Chinese e-commerce giant Alibaba saw…

The App That Democratized Trading Is Now Worth $5B

The App That Democratized Trading Is Now Worth $5B

Investors and customers have rallied…

Ron Paul

Ron Paul

Congressman Ron Paul of Texas enjoys a national reputation as the premier advocate for liberty in politics today. Dr. Paul is the leading spokesman in…

More Info

What's Missing in The Current Immigration 'Crisis' Debate

Over the past several weeks we have seen a significant increase in illegal immigration, as thousands of unaccompanied minors pour across what seems an invisible southern border into the United States. The mass immigration has, as to be expected, put an enormous strain on local resources, and it has heated up the immigration debate in the US.

Most liberals and conservatives miss the point, however, making the same old arguments we have all heard before. Liberals argue that we need to provide more welfare and assistance to these young immigrants, while conservatives would bus them to the other side of the border, drop them off, and deploy drones to keep them out.

Neither side seems interested in considering why is this happening in the first place. The truth is, this latest crisis is a consequence of mistaken government policies on both sides of the border.

In fact much of the problem can be directly traced to the US drug war, which creates unlivable conditions in countries that produce narcotics for export to the US. Many of those interviewed over the past several weeks have cited violent drug gangs back home as a main motivation for their departure. Because some Americans want to use drugs here in the US, governments to the south are bribed and bullied to crack down on local producers. The resulting violence has destroyed economies and lives from Mexico to Nicaragua and beyond. Addressing the failed war on drugs would go a long way to solving the immigration crisis.

I understand the argument of some libertarians that there should be no limits at all on who comes into the United States, but the reality is we do not live in a libertarian society. We live in a society where healthcare is provided -- often by over-burdened emergency rooms that cannot legally turn away the sick -- "free" education is provided, and other support via food stamp programs is also made available for "free" to illegal immigrants. Many even argue that they should be allowed to vote!

In a free society where the warfare-welfare state ceased to exist, immigration laws would be far less important. A free market would seek workers rather than immigrants to add to its welfare rolls. Voting itself would decline in significance. If 20 people lived on a privately-owned island, for example, one owner could decide to have a guest on his property without bothering the other 19. Were we to move in this direction in the US, the current immigration crisis would be a thing of the past.

Over many years while I was in Congress, I met with scores of employers in my district who faced terrible red tape just to be allowed to bring in temporary agricultural workers who would willingly return home once the work was finished. How ironic that Americans willing to provide jobs for immigrants seeking honest work were thwarted by the same government that has now opened the door to a flood of immigrants seeking welfare and other assistance.

One thing we can be sure about: as Republicans and Democrats tussle over "reform" bills, more money will be thrown at the symptoms produced by past bad policies instead of addressing the real causes of the current crisis. The president's $4 billion supplemental request to address the issue is a costly mix of welfare and enforcement that will do very little to solve the problem because it treats the symptoms instead of the cause. Real reform means changing a failed approach, and until that happens we can count on more expensive mistakes.


Back to homepage

Leave a comment

Leave a comment

Sign Up For The Safehaven Newsletter