• 17 hours Gold Is Still A Safe Haven, But Not Very Alluring
  • 1 day What Does CHina’s EV Slowdown Mean For The Battery Metals Sector?
  • 2 days COVID Report Cards Will Brand Businesses Forever
  • 2 days Trump Tweet Sends Oil Soaring 25%
  • 3 days Why The Coronavirus Economic Crash Is Worse Than You Think
  • 3 days Is A Global Currency Necessary?
  • 4 days America Has Shed 500,000 Millionaires Since The Coronavirus Lockdown Began
  • 4 days Trump Wants Another $2 Trillion Economic Intervention
  • 5 days The Surprising Businesses Deemed “Essential” During The Coronavirus Lockdown
  • 5 days Priceless Van Gogh "Spring Garden" Painting Stolen
  • 5 days Oil Falls To $20 For First Time In Nearly Two Decades
  • 5 days COVID-19 Could Be The End Of U.S. Coal
  • 6 days How Much Does Your Social Security Number Cost? $4 On The Dark Web
  • 7 days Silver Stocks Have Been Decimated In The Coronavirus Sell-Off
  • 8 days How Blockchain Tech Could Make Mergers And Acquisitions More Efficient
  • 8 days America’s Shortage Of This Metal Keeps Trump Up At Night
  • 9 days Bidet Bonanza: Defying The Toilet Paper Shortage
  • 9 days U.S. Auto Sales Fall By 75%
  • 10 days Violating Quarantine? Big Brother Is Watching
  • 10 days Does Gold Still Have Some Room To Run?
How The Ultra-Wealthy Are Using Art To Dodge Taxes

How The Ultra-Wealthy Are Using Art To Dodge Taxes

More freeports open around the…

What's Behind The Global EV Sales Slowdown?

What's Behind The Global EV Sales Slowdown?

An economic slowdown in many…

  1. Home
  2. Markets
  3. Other

Imagination Sets In

One of my constant themes over the past few years is the underfunding of state and local pension plans. Illinois is particularly bad, but let's look at some aggregate data.

The National Association of State Retirement Administrators (NASRA) provides this grim-looking annual picture.


Annual Update

State and Local Defined Benefit Plan Assets at Year-End 2003-2014

Between the end of 2007 and end of 2014, pension plan assets rose from $3.29 trillion to $3.71 trillion. That's a total rise of 12.76%.

Plan assumptions are generally between 7.5% to 8.25% per year!


S&P 500 2007-12-31 to 2014-12-31

S&P500 2008-2015 Chart

In the same timeframe, the S&P 500 rose from 1489.36 to 2058.90.

That's a total gain of 590.54 points. Percentage wise that's a total gain of 40.22%. It's also an average gain of approximately 5.75% per year.


Analysis

  • In spite of the miraculous rally from the low, total returns for anyone who held an index throughout has been rather ordinary.
  • The first chart is not a reflection of stocks vs. bonds because bonds did exceptionally well during the same period.


Drawdowns Kill!

To be fair, the first chart only shows assets, not liabilities, but we do know that pensions in general are still enormously underfunded, with Chicago and Illinois leading the way.


Negative Flow

My friend Don Campbell pinged me with this comment the other day: "Nearly all public pension funds have a negative cash flow, meaning they pay out in benefits each year more than they receive in contributions. For all public pension funds, the negative cash flow is approximately 3% of assets, which means an average fund needs to produce an annual return of 3% to maintain a stable asset value."

That's fine if assets have kept up with future payout liabilities and plans are close to fully funded.

However, it is 100% safe to suggest that neither condition is true.

So here we are, after a massive 200% rally from the March 2009 low, and pension plans are still in miserable shape.

And plan assumptions are still an enormous 8% per year. Let me state emphatically, that's not going to happen.

Stocks and junk bonds are enormously overvalued here.


GMO Forecast

GMO 7_year Asset Class Real Return Forecasts

"The chart represents real return forecasts for several asset classes and not for any GMO fund or strategy. These forecasts are forward-looking statements based upon the reasonable beliefs of GMO and are not a guarantee of future performance. Forward-looking statements speak only as of the date they are made, and GMO assumes no duty to and does not undertake to update forward-looking statements. Forward-looking statements are subject to numerous assumptions, risks, and uncertainties, which change over time. Actual results may differ materially from those anticipated in forwardlooking statements. U.S. inflation is assumed to mean revert to long-term inflation of 2.2% over 15 years."

Over the next 7 years GMO believes US stocks will lose money (on average), every year. Those are in real terms, but returns are at best break even, assuming 2% inflation.

Bonds are certainly no safe have either. I strongly believe GMO has this correct.


Assume GMO Wildly Off

Even if one assumes those GMO estimated returns are wildly off to the tune of four percentage points per year, pension plans needing 8% per year will be further in the hole with 4% per year annualized returns.


Imagination

I have a musical tribute to imagination in regards to pension finances, especially imagination in Illinois.


Illinois Non-Answer

Illinois house speaker Michael Madigan and Chicago governor Rahm Emanuel believe tax hikes are the answer.

Both are sorely mistaken. Here are a few viewpoints to consider.

The only way out of this mess is a pension restructuring coupled with municipal defaults.

 

Back to homepage

Leave a comment

Leave a comment