• 10 hours Putin Signs “Digital Iron Curtain” Into Law
  • 13 hours Russian Metals Magnate Sues U.S. Over Sanctions
  • 16 hours Tesla Looks To Jump Into Indian Market
  • 18 hours Global Banks Lay Groundwork To Re-Inflate Asset Prices
  • 1 day Homeowners Experiment With Risky New Investment Trend
  • 2 days U.S. Tech Stocks Look Increasingly Vulnerable
  • 2 days De Beers To Expand World’s Most Profitable Diamond Mine
  • 2 days Ford CEO Gets Raise After Massive Layoff Round
  • 2 days Germany’s Flirtation With Recession Could Cripple The Global Economy
  • 3 days Where To Look As Gold Miners Inch Higher
  • 3 days Google Faces Billions In Fines From European Regulators
  • 4 days The Energy Industry Has A Millennial Problem
  • 4 days Russian Banks Scramble For Sanction Loopholes
  • 5 days Gold ETFs Take A Hit After Four-Month Run
  • 5 days European Union Takes Aim At Ten New Tax Havens
  • 6 days Goldman Defends Trillion-Dollar Corporate Buyback Spree
  • 6 days $600 Billion At Risk As Boeing Fallout Continues
  • 6 days Venezuela Has Yet Another Crisis Developing
  • 6 days Wells Fargo Accused Of “Ongoing Lawlessness”
  • 7 days Hollywood Agency Returns $400M Investment To Saudi Wealth Fund
The Chatroom Cartel Running Global Bond Markets

The Chatroom Cartel Running Global Bond Markets

Eight major banks have been…

Lending: The Good, Bad, And Ugly

Lending: The Good, Bad, And Ugly

Aristotle said, “The most hated…

  1. Home
  2. Markets
  3. Other

Reviving The American Dream

Reviving The American Dream

With Charles Hugh Smith & Gordon T Long

31 Minutes - 18 Slides

Charles Hugh Smith and Gordon T Long follow-up to their discussion last month of the puzzle of the falling US Civilian Labor Participation Rate. In this session they tackle the issues associated with "Universal Basic Income" which the public narrative has begun to 'offer up' as a solution.


Public Narrative

"A Solution to Automation -- Universal Basic Income for all"

The conventional wisdom is that a guaranteed free-money check from the central state is the solution. This is nothing more that "A Redistribution Scheme: A new form of Subsistence Serfdom"

• It doesn't address how this enormously costly program will be paid.

• It is Understood that the "Wealthy" will pay for it!

• Runs aground on the reality that upper-middle class and top 5% already pay 93% of all federal income taxes; they actually can't afford more taxes.

• The top .01% who can afford to pay will continue to buy political protection of their income, and that's not going to change:

http://mobile.nytimes.com/2015/12/30/business/economy/for-the-wealthiest-private-tax-system-saves-them-billions.html


Declining Labor Participation Rate - The Status Quo has no solution!

Declining work force will be unable to pay for the "pay as you go" social programs such as Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid.

Declining labor force will also be unable to support more borrowing -- and the system requires more borrowing just to keep afloat.

Decline of labor is the inevitable result of automation, which has only started eroding white-collar and managerial jobs.

The Reality: New technology creates far fewer jobs than it replaces/destroys

http://www.fastcoexist.com/3054604/todays-tech-giants-are-creating-loads-of-wealth-but-pitifully-few-jobs

The Reality: Today's Tech Giants Are Creating Loads Of Wealth But Pitifully Few Jobs

Why Basic Income is not realistic or positive: http://www.oftwominds.com/blogdec15/basic-income12-15.html

-- Financially unsustainable,

-- A disaster for those getting the welfare check. They are essentially serfs, with no incentives or pathways to build capital.

For the Wealthiest - A Private Tax System That Saves Them Billions

-- ultimately, proponents of basic guaranteed income are relying on borrowing additional trillions of dollars to pay for the scheme. Not only is this financially unsustainable, it is immoral to load debt on future generations to pay for today's spending.

Why Firms Are Fleeing

-- as for expecting corporations to tax trillions more in higher taxes -- they're fleeing US taxes, and they are also buying political favors to avoid higher taxes. http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2016/01/11/why-firms-are-fleeing

Creating Jobs for All


Understanding The Differences

1- The failed model of WELFARE-FOR-ALL - Communal Poverty

• The central-state welfare model

• Top-down, encouraging dependency and helplessness -- and resentment

2- The Social-Economic model of SHARED BENEFITS flowing from working productively together

• The community economy

• Bottom-up, encouraging accumulation of capital, skills, etc.

• Creating the goods and services that are scarce and needed within local communities requires new ways of thinking and organizing work


Subsistance Serfdom

• Giving people money without getting any productive work is destructive to participants,

• Those who have to pay for the free-riders (the community) loses the labor of its residents.

• Our goal should be to provide meaningful work to people in their own communities, not give them subsistence welfare,

• Guaranteed income for all is just a new form of subsistence serfdom.

• Those looking to central state "solutions" such as basic guaranteed income are out of touch with the reality that real solutions come from below, in the entrepreneurial Main Street economy, not from above (central banks, politicians enacting new social programs, etc.)

... and much, much more in this 31 minute frank and open discussion..

 

Back to homepage

Leave a comment

Leave a comment