• 8 hours Can The British Pound Overcome Brexit?
  • 14 hours Is A Gold Breakout Near?
  • 1 day Federal Reserve Downgrades U.S. Growth And Cuts Rate Hikes
  • 1 day Disney Beats Out Comcast In $71.3B Mega-Merger
  • 2 days The Feds Continue To Prop Up Equities Markets
  • 2 days Bejing's Sway In South China Sea Is Fading
  • 2 days Saudis Eye Billions As Stocks Get Emerging Market Boost
  • 2 days Airbnb In Acquisition Mode Ahead Of IPO
  • 3 days Gold Hangs At $1,300 Ahead Of Fed Meeting
  • 3 days Champagne Sales Slow As European Economic Worries Grow Louder
  • 3 days Putin Signs “Digital Iron Curtain” Into Law
  • 3 days Russian Metals Magnate Sues U.S. Over Sanctions
  • 4 days Tesla Looks To Jump Into Indian Market
  • 4 days Global Banks Lay Groundwork To Re-Inflate Asset Prices
  • 4 days Homeowners Experiment With Risky New Investment Trend
  • 4 days U.S. Tech Stocks Look Increasingly Vulnerable
  • 5 days De Beers To Expand World’s Most Profitable Diamond Mine
  • 5 days Ford CEO Gets Raise After Massive Layoff Round
  • 5 days Germany’s Flirtation With Recession Could Cripple The Global Economy
  • 6 days Where To Look As Gold Miners Inch Higher
Ford CEO Gets Raise After Massive Layoff Round

Ford CEO Gets Raise After Massive Layoff Round

Despite a massive layoff round…

Russian Metals Magnate Sues U.S. Over Sanctions

Russian Metals Magnate Sues U.S. Over Sanctions

Oleg Deripaska, a Russian metals…

Alex Kimani

Alex Kimani

Writer, Divergente Research LLC

Alex Kimani is a veteran finance writer, investor, engineer and researcher for Divergente Research LLC and Safehaven.com. 

Contact Author

  1. Home
  2. News
  3. Breaking News

China’s ‘Black Mirror’: Millions Banned From Travel

China Black Mirror

China is in the process of setting up a vast surveillance system that will track every single one of its 1.4 billion citizens in a drive that includes an Orwellian social credit system that Beijing rolled out last year, ranking citizens based on behavior and doling out rewards or punishment based on scores.

And now, the Chinese are beginning to get a taste of the real-life ‘Black Mirror.’

A report by Associated Press says that the government blocked people from buying plane or train tickets a grand total of 23 million times last year because of low social credit scores.

People were blocked from buying high-speed train tickets 5.5. million times and from purchasing airline tickets 17.5 million times for various offenses including failure to pay taxes or fines.

That’s a nearly fourfold increase compared to last year’s collective figure of 6.5 million.

Social grading

The idea of social credit was first mooted circa 2007 before the government launched several opt-in systems in 2014. China’s social grading system has been compared to Big Brother, Black Mirror and many other dystopian future sci-fi labels. While not exactly a world first, the country’s surveillance system will be unique-- and worse—than anything else that preceded it once it’s complete around 2020.

Most countries do have some sort of citizen grading system. Credit checks are almost universal wherein data brokers trace the timely manner in which we pay our debts. Lenders and mortgage providers use these credit scores to evaluate our creditworthiness. We also have social-style scores that we use on online sites like Amazon and eBay while Uber drivers and passengers rate each other. Related: Gold Jewelry Fuels $20 Billion Valentine’s Spending Spree

China’s social credit system takes this idea to a whole new level. Caught jaywalking, playing your music too loud on the train, fail to pay a court bill or your taxes and you risk losing certain rights including booking a flight or train ticket. The country does not as yet have a single nationally coordinated social credit system but rather local governments have their own social record systems.

No one us sure of the exact methods that the government is going to use to monitor its citizens. But the final system is likely to be downright creepy if currently available technologies are any indication. Here are some of the social surveillance systems already in use in China:

#1. Facial recognition technology

At least 16 provinces, cities and municipalities across the country already use facial reconition systems to scan citizens with a 99.8 percent accuracy. Last year, police  using facial recognition systems managed to locate and arrest a suspect in 60,000-person pop concert.

#2. Group chats admins spying on people

The Beijing government holds people criminally liable for content posted in group chats. The regulation applies even to private and encrypted apps such as WhatsApp. The government also requires tech companies to monitor and report any illegal activities to the authorities.

#3. Forced installation of spying apps

US-funded Open Technology Fund has reported that the government forced Uighurs, a small ethnic community in western China, to download a spying app that scans videos, photos, ebooks, and other files and sends the information to an outside server.

#4. Spying on people’s online shopping habits

The Communist Party wants citizens to be responsible and on their best behavior,  and people who spend frivolously by buying non-essentials are penalized under the social credit system. For instance, people who play too many video games are labeled irresponsible and slapped with a low score while buying diapers online is likely to be seen as a good thing and elicit higher scores.

#5.  Your car spying on you

More than 200 automakers that sell electric vehicles in China send at least 61 data points to government-backed monitoring programs under rules published in 2016. These include American and European manufacturers such as Tesla, General Motors, Ford, BMW, Volkswagen and Daimler.

By Alex Kimani for Safehaven.com

More Top Reads From Safehaven.com:

Back to homepage

Leave a comment
  • Godfree Roberts on March 08 2019 said:
    "China is in the process of setting up a vast surveillance system that will track every single one of its 1.4 billion citizens in a drive that includes an Orwellian social credit system that Beijing rolled out last year, ranking citizens based on behavior and doling out rewards or punishment based on scores."

    Ten years ago Beijing asked people to find ways to reward the 99% of ordinary good citizens while discouraging the other 1%. The idea was for for everyone to raise their game, end littering, oafishness, cheating, public nuisances and deadbeats without taking draconian measures.

    Some tried comprehensive systems of reward and punishment and their findings are available online. Most tried eliminating pet peeves (inconsiderate dog owners were high on everyone's list). Some results were hilarious, some disappointing, some brilliant and many are still running while being tweaked and benchmarked.

    The best will parade their data in a national beauty contest late this year and, by 2021 the best regional experiments will be combined and national trials will begin to tweak them until public approval hits 90%, the threshold for introducing binding legislation by the mid-20s.

    It's much more carrot than stick and, Chinese friends assure me, well suited to Chinese society (which runs on very, very different assumptions than ours). The idea is to use social engineering to create a trusting, trustworthy, hassle-free society. The goal is for most folks will be able to borrow money or hire a car or board an airplane without being questioned or even stopped.So watch and enjoy the biggest social experiment in world history as good folks finally get a little respect and assholes don't.

    It's also popular, as this survey by a German academic, reveals: "China’s Social Credit Systems and Public Opinion:Explaining High Levels of Approval" Genia Kostka, Freie Universität Berlin. (g.kostka@fu-berlin.de)

Leave a comment